Article
Convert MP3 to Lossless
Ask iLounge offers readers the opportunity to get answers to their iPod-, iPhone-, iPad-, iTunes-, or Apple TV-related questions from a member of the iLounge editorial team. We'll answer several questions here each week, and of course, you can always get help with more immediate concerns from the iLounge Discussion Forums. Submit your questions for consideration using our Ask iLounge Submit Form. We reserve the right to edit questions for grammar, spelling, and length.
Q: I have a second-generation iPod nano and I have recently purchased an 80 GB iPod classic for home stereo use. I want to transfer the existing nano iTunes playlist to my new classic but, once transferred, I also want to convert the songs in that playlist from a 128 kbps bitrate to Apple Lossless for better sound quality. Does it matter, in terms of sound quality, whether I carry out that conversion using the iTunes preferences or would it be better for me to re-digitize my entire CD collection to iTunes from scratch?
- Parker
A: This actually matters a great deal. Converting a 128kbps audio file to any higher bitrate will not result in any improvement in sound quality—merely a larger file size at the same quality. In other words, there’s no point in even bothering to do this—you won’t get any improvement in audio quality.
Low bit-rate audio formats such as MP3 and AAC accomplish their small file sizes through the use of what is known as “lossy” compression. Essentially this means that the music track is analyzed, and certain audio content is discarded completely from the resulting file. Most of the time, this discarded content is in frequencies that cannot be heard by the average person using average equipment, and therefore is unnoticeable by most people. Of course, the higher the bit-rate, the more information is retained, which is why there is much debate about the quality of different bit-rates—something that is almost always a completely subjective decision based on your own ears and the equipment that you are using to listen to your music.
For comparative purposes, an original CD audio track is encoded at 1,440 kbps, or 1,440,000 bits of data for each second of audio. On the other hand, a 128kbps MP3 file only contains 128,000 bits of data for each second of audio. This means that in a 128kbps MP3 file, you have effectively lost 1,312,000 bits of information per second. This has been stripped out of the resulting MP3 file during the initial conversion process, and is never coming back. Therefore, converting this 128kbps MP3 file back to an original CD audio track is basically going to insert 1,312,000 bits of dead air into each second of audio—you’ll end up with a larger file with no actual increase in sound quality. In short, you can’t get data back that wasn’t there in the first place.
On the other hand, as their name implies, lossless formats such as Apple Lossless compress the audio stream without losing any data. The result is a smaller file at the equivalent quality of the original CD. The resulting file sizes of Apple Lossless files vary depending upon the original source, since some audio files will compress better than others, but on average they’re usually around 50-70% of the original CD track. Further, since these are lossless formats, they can be used to burn audio CDs, or re-convert to other audio formats in the same way the original audio CD could be—all of the original audio information is present, it’s merely compressed into a smaller file size (in much the same way that a ZIP file works).
So if you’re converting to any higher quality format, whether it’s Apple Lossless or simply a higher bit-rate MP3, you should always re-rip from a lossless source (ie, the original CD), since there’s absolutely no point in doing the conversion otherwise.
For more information and discussion about the various digital audio formats and the relative merits of each, be sure to check out our Digital Audio Formats forum in the iLounge Discussion Forums.
Related Stories
- Will removing a credit card from Safari also remove it from Apple Pay?
- Can I mute Handoff calls coming into my Mac from my iPhone?
- How do I keep my iPhone calls from ringing on my Mac?
- Why doesn’t Traffic show up on my Today Notifications Screen?
- Why doesn’t my iPhone reconnect to Wi-Fi after I turn it on?
- Why can’t I see the iPad-style landscape view on my iPhone 6 Plus?
Recent News
- OtterBox releases new case designs for Solo: A Star Wars Story
- Agile Tortoise releases Drafts 5
- Report: New iPhone models may be coming this spring, likely iPhone SE updates
- Cultured Code releases Things 3.5 with better tag filtering and other UI improvements
- August Apple Watch app now allows untethered Smart Lock control
- Apple to leverage Texture acquisition to bring new magazine subscription plan to Apple News
- About explains ‘Hey Siri’ personalization in Machine Learning Journal
- Apple releases second developer betas for iOS 11.4, tvOS 11.4, watchOS 4.3.1
- Apple will repair 42mm Apple Watch Series 2 models with swollen batteries free of charge
- Code in watchOS 4.3.1 suggests faint possibility of third-party Apple Watch faces
Recent Reviews
- Fluance Fi70 Three-Way Wireless High Fidelity Music System
- Creative Labs Sound BlasterX Katana Multi-Channel Gaming Soundbar
- Case-Mate Power Pad Wireless Charger
- Solis SO-8000 Stereo Bluetooth Vacuum Tube Audio System
- FurniQi Wireless Charging Side Table
- Marshall Mid ANC Bluetooth Headphones
- Divoom ADOT Speaker for Amazon Echo Dot
- Beyerdynamic DT 770 Pro & DT 990 Pro Over-Ear Headphones
- Creative Aurvana Trio In-Ear Headphones
- 808 Audio XL-V Wireless Smart Speaker
Recent Articles
- Sponsored: 10 iPhone X Wireless Charging Stands & Docks
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of iOS 11
- Inside the betas: watchOS 4.1 adds Apple Music streaming
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of watchOS 4
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of tvOS 11
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of iTunes 12.7
- Inside the betas: iOS 11 Control Center gets customizable, adds Screen Recording
- Inside the betas: iOS 11 HomeKit adds timers, multi-person occupancy support
- Inside the betas: tvOS 11 adds auto Dark Mode, iCloud Home Screen Sync
- Top Five: The Best Products for Building a Smart Home with HomeKit