Editorial: iTunes Ping - Apple’s Facebook Rival, Or Much, Much Less? | iLounge Article

Article

Editorial: iTunes Ping - Apple’s Facebook Rival, Or Much, Much Less?

While others have rushed to write off or hype up Ping, the music-focused social network introduced by Apple two days ago, we’re not going to do either of those things today—it’s just too early. Surely Twitter saw more than its fair share of obituaries before establishing itself as a service to be reckoned with, and few could have dreamed that Facebook would achieve global ubiquity after launching as a profile site for Harvard students in 2004. Yet Ping isn’t Twitter, and it isn’t Facebook: despite Apple efforts to collaborate with these services, it looks and feels like a trojan horse to eventually challenge these and other social networks, leveraging the strength of its iTunes customer base to get a leg up on competitors who have struggled for their first million or ten million users.

 

image

Today’s implementation of Ping takes two forms: on Macs and PCs running iTunes 10, it is a modest component of the iTunes Store found either on the left side bar of the application under iTunes Store, or on the top bar within the Store next to iTunes U. Here, Ping looks a lot like a limited form of Facebook, letting you set up a brief profile with a single picture, some descriptive text, and up to 10 songs you like. Then, you can monitor “recent activity” taking place with your contacts—people you follow, or who follow you—as well as seeing options for adding more contacts, and monitoring song and album charts showing the top music purchases made by people you follow. Additional pages let you edit your profile, monitor reviews you’ve posted on iTunes, and see lists of contacts, followers, and people Apple recommends that users follow.

Apple has structured Ping with reasonable privacy settings, though there’s a lot less here to protect than on services such as Facebook. You can be completely public, share your comments and content only with friends, or be completely private—you can also opt to never sign up for Ping at all. If you share only with friends, you need to manually approve your followers one by one, with email advisories every time you get a new request. Bear in mind that you may be exposing iTunes purchases and other details to a broad audience by being completely public, so you may need to edit down your profile to share only details you’re comfortable letting other people know about.

 

image

The grayer, simpler iOS version of Ping is available within the iTunes application, but only on iOS 4.x devices—sorry, iPadders. It features the same general features, minus the editing capabilities and with less emphasis on Apple recommendations. Neither version makes it as easy to find new contacts as it could; a planned Facebook Connect feature was yanked shortly after Ping launched due to contract issues between Apple and Facebook.

 

image

But Apple’s recommendations of contacts you should follow are apparently powerful. Minutes after launching Ping, Lady GaGa had around 400 followers—likely Apple beta testers. Two days later, she has over 156,000 more followers. Most users are in the tens or hundreds, with few in the thousands. As Chris Martin suggested during the Apple event, this is proof positive that Apple’s marketing is capable of popularizing anything, and a suggestion of just how much sway it will have for artists as Ping’s user base continues to grow.

Will it continue to grow? We’re going to bet that the answer is “yes,” though the value of the service right now is truly very modest by comparison with Facebook and even Twitter. Ping just isn’t as useful. In addition to letting you track artists and concerts, it’s there largely to let you see what your contacts are buying and recommending—again, only music, and then only music that Apple sells in your specific country.

A week-old Jamiroquai track available in France’s iTunes Store but not in the United States one can’t be purchased, liked, or shared with contacts if you’re writing about it using a U.S. iTunes account. If a friend in a different country posts comments on tracks that aren’t sold in your country, you won’t even see them. For now, this is a social network where you can only talk and be heard about specific subjects. Additionally, the idea of commenting just for the sake of commenting—sharing your current status or thoughts as you would on Facebook or Twitter—isn’t there. Comments are only there for you and your contacts to annotate existing posts, purchases, or the addition of new contacts. They may well be buried and never even seen if you have a lot of contacts.

As it turns out, Apple has created two classes of user accounts: Artists and People. Somewhat ironically, Artists get to comment on Ping without specifically selling you anything, and can post photos, videos, and possibly other content at will. People, including you, are there to comment on and purchase content from the Artists, not to share pictures, videos, or even thoughts if they’re unrelated to music content in the Store. These limitations create a very odd and conceptually unsettling system, at least if you take Apple’s claim that this is a “social network” seriously.

Our suspicion is that Apple will change this structure dramatically over time—unless it really wants Ping to be nothing more than a “find it in iTunes, tell your friends” selling tool for music. Changes are so easy for the company to make that they can appear at any time without even requiring a new version of iTunes or the iOS iTunes application. But perhaps that’s all Apple aspires to do: empower iTunes users just enough to sell more stuff from the Store, adding movies, TV shows, and apps over the weeks and months that follow. Should that be the service’s only draw, we’d be surprised if people are still actively using it a year from now, or perhaps even a month from now. It has a lot of potential, but Apple will need to make some major improvements before Ping merits more than occasional check-ins. Absent a more engaging social environment, users won’t want to serve as unpaid iTunes Store pitch people for very long.

« Instant Expert: Secrets and Features of iOS 4.1 for iPhone + iPod touch

iPhone + iPad Gems: Epic Citadel, Let’s Create! Pottery HD, No, Human, Social, Twitter + More »

Related Stories

Comments

1

Also, content, such as photos or videos, shared by Artists, is not viewable everywhere… with my Mexican iTunes Store account I can only see the text but not the photos or videos.

If I log-in with my US iTunes account, I can see them perfectly whether on my Mac or my iPhone…

Posted by Korpil on September 3, 2010 at 5:42 PM (CDT)

2

I have been unable to “ping” from my iPhone 4 since reading your article. Get a “unable to connect to iTunes Store” error message.

Posted by Richard Rogers-Berry on September 3, 2010 at 5:54 PM (CDT)

3

Well, i found quite interesting to look into my fav artists tastes. It inform you of theyr real influences. And you can well find new artist you can like.

Posted by Pvc on September 3, 2010 at 5:58 PM (CDT)

4

So far, Ping is a big failure. No Facebook/Twitter integration and complicated interface/navigation. It certainly wasn’t ready for prime time yet. Jobs should have held on to this one a little longer before releasing to the masses.

Posted by Ryan on September 4, 2010 at 7:22 AM (CDT)

5

iTunes on iPhone 4 now comes with a Ping integration button that just tells me to start iTunes on my PC and use Ping there. Oddly unsatisfying, given that I also have the separate Ping app on the iPhone. Got to hope this comes together soon.

Posted by Martin Johnson on September 4, 2010 at 8:55 PM (CDT)

6

You need to activate your account for Ping using iTunes on your PC before you will be able to access it through the iTunes app on your iPhone.

I’m also not sure what separate Ping app you’re referring to on the iPhone, as there is no app for Apple’s Ping service that I’m aware of.  There was a device-to-device messaging app named “Ping” at one point, but that has nothing to do with Apple’s new service beyond sharing the same name.

Posted by Jesse Hollington in Toronto on September 4, 2010 at 11:19 PM (CDT)

7

I got it up and running on the first day and had a bit of a “now what?” moment.  I know it’s still -really- early days and there are kinks to work out, but I’ve only found one artist I like and one person to follow (incidentally, the artist’s personal account).

I really wish they’d lined up a wider variety of artists prior to launch, and an opt-in directory of some sort for “People” if they were having issues with Facebook/Twitter integration.  It just doesn’t seem very social for a social network right now. :/

Posted by Char on September 5, 2010 at 10:56 PM (CDT)

8

It also appears that Apple has not been very forthcoming about how Artists can actually get artist accounts.  Saw a tweet from Weird Al a couple of days ago, indicating that he had set up a normal end-user Ping profile, but couldn’t figure out how to actually become an “Artist” even though his stuff is sold on iTunes.

Posted by Jesse Hollington in Toronto on September 6, 2010 at 11:50 AM (CDT)

9

While I wait for iTunes 10.0.1 (the bug fix version), can someone tell me if this worthless feature can be disabled - hidden from view, and prevented from interfering with other iTunes functions?

It’s “worthless” because (1) this is one wheel Apple didn’t need to reinvent, and (2) a mature, rational, thinking person with a social life in the REAL (not virtual) world doesn’t need yet another insipid “social network,” least of all one half full of bubble-headed celebrities.

Posted by Farnsworth on September 7, 2010 at 10:12 AM (CDT)

10

Unfortunately, you can’t hide it from the source list on the left—it will stay stuck there in between the iTunes Store and Purchased playlists. However, it’s a complete “opt-in” setup much like the Genius feature, so if you never turn it on, it shouldn’t get in the way of anything even in the iTunes Store.

However, even when enabled, Ping doesn’t show up anywhere else in the iTunes application outside of the iTunes Store itself, so it shouldn’t interfere with any other iTunes functions whether it’s enabled or not.

Posted by Jesse Hollington in Toronto on September 7, 2010 at 11:17 AM (CDT)

11

Unfortunately there isn’t enought info here to use in an essay :(

Posted by Nialler on October 8, 2011 at 8:34 AM (CDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods/iPhones/iPad or accessories, or if you sell or market iPod/iPhone/iPad products or services, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy