How to fill a 5Gb iPod | iLounge Article

Article

How to fill a 5Gb iPod

So here’s what the thing would be if I were really bored and absurdly anal on a Sunday early-evening… As an iPod early-adopter, I may be the last person left in the Western hemisphere with a mere 5GB to fill. And I’ve ripped nearly 12Gb of my own albums onto my computer. So I clearly have a problem here - how do I choose what to put onto it? Of the 2822 songs currently on my Mac, only 535 songs have yet to be rated (star ratings out of five - rating songs is the new ‘alphabetizing my record collection’), and these include several new albums I’ve bought recently along with some older stuff that I don’t really want to write off just yet, but at the same time can’t really say that I’ve demonstrated much inclination to listen to either…

There are several considerations - one being the highly frustrating way that the iTunes randomize function only randomizes the first time you make a playlist - so you can’t have one list that changes dynamically. This is highly frustrating.

Quickly - some dumb figures: 5 star songs: 281,  4 star songs: 991, 3 star songs: 691, 2 star songs: 286, 1 star songs: 38. In principle the scoring mechanism that has evolved works like this - I would not be averse to listening to at any time any song that gets three to five stars. Two star songs are an irritation. One star songs are just irredeemably awful. One star songs are mostly from Moby’s “18” or represent the most self-indulgent of The Magnetic Fields’ oeuvre… Other considerations to bear in mind - classical music is interesting, but not always ideal for listening to on the bus or down the street, I add new music all the time and wish it to be represented on my iPod before I have had the chance to assign it a rating, humorous songs often become less humorous after a fairly short amount of time. There are many many other criteria in play here as well - so many in fact that ideally I would need someone to do some comprehensive analysis on the subject and return to me with a set of criteria that one could use as a basis for evolving appropriate smart playlists. Here’s my attempt so far…

  • 5-star songs:
    This smart playlist operates according to the following principles:
    My rating is 5-stars, Genre is not Educational or Classical, limited to 1210 Mb selected by random.
    Significantly, this represents essentially every single 5-star song I own except for a batch of scientific songs by Tom Glazer that may be empiracally wonderful but can become irritating, and classical pieces which are often simply too long to warrant inclusion.

  • 4-star songs:
    This smart playlist operates according to the following principles:
    My rating is 4-stars, Genre is not Educational, Classical or Humour, limited to 650 songs selected by random.
    This represents 2.69Gb of the space on my iPod, except that since several of my smart playlists randomly select some of the same tracks, there is no particular benefit in specifying exactly how much space it should occupy. This is a fairly savagely cut selection from the 991 songs that I’ve given a full four stars too. There simply isn’t space to do otherwise. Note the addition of humour to the banned genre… Five star comedy may remain entertaining… Four star may not…

  • 4-star songs (running):
    This smart playlist operates according to the following principles:
    My rating is 4-stars, Genre is not Educational, Classical or Humour, limited to 200 songs selected by date added.
    Now we have to add an element of movement into the organisation of the iPod. Since we can only have a selection of the four-star songs that are available, a choice has to be made as to which ones will be chosen. A purely random selection that isn’t dynamically different each time would relegate some songs to obscurity, and more importantly would remain uniformly distributed - there would be no sense of progress… By choosing the 200 most recently added 4-star songs, I make sure that my iPod changes and responds to my daily whim…

  • Most Played:
    This smart playlist operates according to the following principles:
    My rating is better than 2 stars, limited to 300 songs selected by most played.
    This list has precisely the opposite function of the one above - to be a stable chart of songs that I seem to not want to be without. The removal of anything with a rating under 3 stars makes sure I don’t accidentally get stuck with something I’ve come to hate.

  • Recent Additions:
    This smart playlist operates according to the following principles:
    My rating is not 1 stars / 2 stars / or 3 stars, limited to 60 songs selected by recently added.
    Essentially this list is simply to catch stuff that I’ve added but have not as yet come to a conclusion about. The removal of anything with one, two or three stars means that I don’t waste time listening to stuff that I have come to a conclusion about, while anything that has yet to be rated remains included.

  • Recently Played:
    This smart playlist operates according to the following principles:
    My rating is not 1 or 2 stars / or 3 stars, limited to 40 Mb, selected by last played.
    Because it’s possible that I could have a song in my head when I leave my flat, and for it not to be on my iPod, I instituted a list that kept track of what had been listened to in roughly the last forty minutes and made sure that was always with me. A tiny additional list that has been a complete life-saver many times…

This feels a bit Open University-esque. It’s an almost total waste of weblog space as well. Except that I am serious - if someone out there has done some research into these things I’m sure that a company like Apple would be interested… A default ‘my music collection’ playlist that intuited what kind of things you actually wanted to carry around with you (with whatever obscure algorithm it used) would probably be quite appealing to some people…

« Wishing for a play queue for iPod

Audio Formats Explained And Rated »

Related Stories

Comments

1

We have a script, called Make A Bunch Random,
that will allow you to select several Smart Playlists, which it will combine into one playlist and shuffle.

Doug

Posted by Doug Adams on April 22, 2003 at 11:22 AM (PDT)

2

You might also check out these five iPod scripts, four of which are designed to fill iPods up in varying ways.

Posted by eustacescrubb in Yellow Springs. OH on April 23, 2003 at 3:23 AM (PDT)

3

I have a 5 GB iPod as well, and I fill it using a set of smart playlists:
- Audible Files: Kind is “Audible file”. I’m into books on tape, so I make sure they’re all on the iPod. I uncheck the ones that I’ve listened to, so they’re displayed in the iTunes playlist for reference, but not copied to the iPod.
- Favorites: Limit to 1 GB selected by highest rating.
- Recently Added: Limit to 1 GB selected by most recently added.
- Purchased Music: as Apple defined it. if I paid for it, I want to listen to it. (At least for now)
- Random Music: Limit to 2 GB selected by random. I like having this so that I’ve got “new” music to listen to every time i synch my iPod.

A few feature requests (in case an iPod engineer reads this):
- Add a ‘shuffle’ command to cause random smart playlists to re-randomize.
- Have ‘convert selection to AAC’ ask whether to remove the old tracks. I’ve been converting my 192k bps MP3’s to 128k bps AAC’s, and it’s amazingly tedious double checking to make sure that I delete the right MP3’s after conversion is done.
- I’m also finding that deleting tracks from iTunes (e.g. the MP3 versions of tracks I just converted to AAC’s) doesn’t always delete the MP3’s. So I have untold MB of disk space wasted on invisible music times. I’d like to be able to force a scan of the iTunes folders to make sure that all songs physically present are in iTunes, and vice versa.

Posted by Laird Popkin in New York City on May 11, 2003 at 2:58 PM (PDT)

4

Uh, it’s called AAC.  Get the new update for it, and compress your stuff overnight to 64 or 56 kb/second.  It sounds just as good as 128 MP3, and you can fit everything on it.

Posted by I'm Not giving my name to this website... in I'm Not giving my location to this website... on May 13, 2003 at 1:46 PM (PDT)

5

I have converted all of my high bitrate MP3’s to 128 kbps AAC’s, but I’ve still got 25 GB or so of music, and a 5 GB iPod.

Posted by Laird Popkin in NYC on May 21, 2003 at 5:36 AM (PDT)

6

i would like to know what i should buy after i get my 10GB ipod and what is the difference between all of the ipods and where should i buy mine.

Posted by JustinDorn on September 28, 2003 at 11:18 AM (PDT)

7

all og y’all with 5gb ipods: buy a new one
i know, it may be hard to part with it, but it’s worth it.

Posted by dan on January 2, 2004 at 7:13 PM (PDT)

8

I’ve unchecked lots (and I mean LOTS) of my music, but when i try to sync ALL the songs show up on the list and iTunes tells me there is not room on my tiny 5 GB iPod for everything.  What am I doing wrong here - aside from trying to do anything with a PC (be gentle!)

Posted by jess on January 29, 2004 at 9:28 PM (PDT)

9

Jess, you have to go into the iPod options panel, I believe, and check the “only update checked songs” option. I think that should work.

Posted by Me on April 2, 2004 at 4:02 AM (PDT)

10

you can score a nice 15GB on eBay for under $200 easily, or pick up a refurb 30GB from apple.com for only $349.

Posted by m3th on June 2, 2004 at 7:36 AM (PDT)

11

I WANT TO KNOW IF THERE IS ANY OTHER
WAY TO INTERFACE WITH THE IPOD USING A PC WITH WINDOWS WITHOUT USING TO WINDOWS XP SOFTWARE?

Posted by TAMIKA on August 12, 2004 at 10:49 AM (PDT)

12

I have just bought a 20gb IPOD…please can anyone tell me how the hell to transfer music from PC..to IPOD,it does not do it automatically as it is supposed to.I would have thrown it ,if it had not been so expensive….please Help…Eve

Posted by TreezaGreen in Wilts on August 16, 2004 at 10:24 AM (PDT)

13

right click your ipod icon and it is most likely set to manually organise music, you need to chnage that to automatic.

Posted by Robin Hood on August 25, 2004 at 1:00 PM (PDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods/iPhones/iPad or accessories, or if you sell or market iPod/iPhone/iPad products or services, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy