iPhone Gems: Apple’s Pages, Numbers, and Keynote 1.4 Reviewed
When Apple originally debuted the iPad last year, the company also brought its iWork suite of applications to the new tablet, positioning iPads as more effective document creation devices than iPhones and iPod touches—while also demonstrating that software would enable an iPad to be more than the oversized iPod touch pundits had predicted.
As we noted in our earlier reviews, the original versions of the three iWork apps—Pages, Numbers and Keynote—were about equal parts groundbreaking for what they brought to the iPad and disappointing by comparison to what users of the Mac versions had come to expect. All three of the apps have seen modest updates over the past year, addressing some of the earlier issues we noted, expanding file compatibility and sharing capabilities, while also adding AirPrint support with the release of iOS 4.2 last fall. Even with these updates, however, it remains clear that Apple’s vision for iWork on the iPad is to provide a set of apps that are merely good enough for casual everyday use, with their more sophisticated Mac counterparts required for advanced projects.
When Apple originally released these apps, many people wondered if versions would eventually arrive for the iPhone and iPod touch; others questioned whether they would even be practical on the smaller-screened devices. With version 1.4 of Pages, Numbers, and Keynote, Apple has provided an answer to the first question—all three apps are now universal—while the second question remains a subjective one. In today’s Gems piece, we take a closer look at the iPhone and iPod touch implementations of these apps while also providing a quick overview of some of the newer features they’ve gained across platforms.
In addition to iPhone and iPod touch support, all three apps added several other common new features since our original review. They include support for importing and exporting files via iDisk and other WebDAV servers, significant improvements to Microsoft Office file compatibility, and a new document management interface that adds folder support. Gone are the prior controls at the bottom of the apps’ document selection screens, replaced instead with a single plus button in the top left corner that is used both to create a new document or import a file from iTunes, iDisk or a WebDAV server. File export controls have been removed from this screen entirely, and are now found on a new “Share and Print” menu on the settings screen when viewing or editing a specific document.
Documents are also now displayed as a series of thumbnails rather than using the prior “Cover Flow” view. This change makes way for a new folders feature that is almost identical in basic design to the way apps are reorganized on the iOS Home Screen; tapping and holding on a document will enter a management mode where documents can be dragged atop one another to create folders. In this mode you can also select multiple documents by tapping on their thumbnails and move them to folders in groups or use the buttons in the top-right corner to duplicate or delete the documents.
The same document management interface used on the iPad is also available when using the apps on the iPhone and iPod touch.
Beyond the new document management features common to all three apps, Pages 1.4 on the iPad remains basically the same as the prior version. The major new feature here is the addition of iPhone and iPod touch support. Pages on the smaller screen essentially provides the same features as on the iPad, with a few interface tweaks appropriate for the smaller devices. The most conspicuous omission here is the complete absence of any kind of landscape support; Pages on the iPhone and iPod touch runs in portrait mode only, both for viewing and editing documents. Users will be limited to the smaller keyboard layout when editing documents; Bluetooth keyboards are supported, of course, but even in this case the app is still confined to a portrait orientation.
To aid with working on the smaller screen, Apple has implemented a new “Smart Zoom” feature in the iPhone and iPod touch version of Pages, auto-zooming in on the cursor position or selected text to allow you to more easily see what you’re working with. Pages provides a more distinct “edit mode” in order to support this feature; tapping on a block of text or other area in the document engages editing mode, simultaneously placing the cursor and zooming on its position. A “Done” button appears in the top right corner to exit editing mode and return to the full-page document view.
In editing mode, the Smart Zoom feature not only follows the cursor but also adjusts the zoom level as required when selecting text or moving between different-sized paragraphs. This feature is most apparent when using cursor positioning and text selection keys on an external keyboard, and actually works quite intuitively to ensure that the user is provided with the most effective view of whatever they’re working on.
As expected from the UI differences between the iPad and iPhone/iPod touch, the pop-over UI dialog boxes found on the iPad have been replaced with modal screens on the smaller devices. Due to limited screen space, Apple also chose to exclude the ruler bar and formatting toolbar that appears when editing text on the iPad. The same options are all still available, but users will find themselves switching between screens rather than working with an overlay or toolbar. Formatting and layout options use a split-screen view to allow you to see your selected text while applying font and style changes; other options such as media selection and settings are displayed as a full-screen view. A down arrow appears in the top-right corner of each screen, acting as a “Close” button to dismiss the screen.
Text and object selection and context menus work in much the same way as on the iPad; tapping-and-holding on a selected block of text or other object will present a context-menu for the usual iOS-level copy and paste options plus additional options for copying styles, looking up word definitions and inserting tabs and breaks. With the omission of the iPad toolbar, this context menu—or an external keyboard—is the only way to actually insert a tab character.
Pages has been through a number of incremental changes in the past year, generally improving the user experience and addressing compatibility issues when working with Mac Pages and Microsoft Word documents. Although it remains a “lite” app in contrast to the Mac version, it has also remained the most capable word processing app for the iPad, even alongside Microsoft Office-focused suites that have been ported from other platforms. Due to nothing more than the respective screen limitations of the devices, Pages is definitely still a much better solution for the iPad than the iPhone and iPod touch. That said, however, Apple has done as good a job as possible of creating an intuitive and usable word processing app for the smaller screen. The addition of iDisk and WebDAV support last year was also a major improvement in the ability to access files on the go, although we would still prefer to see a more integrated way of working with “live” documents rather than the current process of having to go through a separate import and export stage to move documents in and out of the app. iLounge Rating: B.
Numbers 1.4 ($10) is also basically just a universal update to the prior iPad app, adding the aforementioned new common document management features and iPhone and iPod touch support. As with Pages, Numbers on the iPhone and iPod touch is limited to portrait mode, regardless of whether you’re using the on-screen keyboard or an external Bluetooth keyboard. A set of tabs for each sheet appears at the top of the screen as on the iPad, and the Smart Zoom feature dynamically zooms in when editing a cell. In this case, simply selecting a cell by tapping on it doesn’t engage the Smart Zoom; a second tap is required to actually enter “edit” mode.
In edit mode, the cell content field is displayed at the top of the screen with a checkmark button to the right to accept the entry and exit edit mode; users can alternatively tap on a different cell to switch to that cell and remain in edit mode, and even move around the spreadsheet or pinch to zoom in and out to select cells that are not otherwise in view. The feature works well, feeling very natural and intuitive on the smaller screen.
The keyboard selection buttons from the iPad also appear here below the entry field, allowing users to choose between a numeric, date/time, text or formula keyboard. Each keyboard layout has been redesigned specifically for the smaller iPhone/iPod touch screens, providing the same options in a more optimized layout. Unfortunately, some of the new keyboard layouts—particularly the formulas keyboard—will take some getting used to compared to the iPad version; Numbers on the smaller screen doesn’t have the luxury of spreading out and separating the keys as on the iPad.
As in Pages, options and settings are presented as either a split-screen view for formatting controls or as separate screens for inserting media and other objects or adjusting settings. A close button in the top-right corner allows users to exit the options screen. On the iPhone, Numbers provides the same context menus and selection controls as it does on the iPad. Users can tap-and-hold to bring up context menus, tap-and-drag to select multiple cells, and even hold-tap-and-drag to move cells to another area on the spreadsheet.
Numbers has followed much the same update path as Pages, with incremental changes to improve the user experience and improve compatibility with Mac Numbers and Microsoft Excel, notably also adding the previously missing ability to export in a Microsoft Excel format late last year. Like Pages, it continues to provide the best spreadsheet experience among all of the iPad spreadsheet apps we’ve seen, even despite not having the feature set that a Numbers or Excel “power user” might come to expect, and the iPhone and iPod touch version again does a strong job of making the app’s powerful features work well on the smaller screens. The only reservations with Numbers are the same ones we noted earlier regarding Pages; creating documents on such small devices remains a challenge, and the import/export process makes working with and sharing documents with the Mac version more cumbersome than it needs to be. iLounge Rating: B.
Keynote 1.4 ($10) is the third app in the iWork suite and has been similarly updated for iPhone and iPod touch support. In this case, however, the new version also adds another interesting feature for both iPad and iPhone/iPod touch users: support for Apple’s standalone Keynote Remote app.
Released over two years ago, Apple’s Keynote Remote is a $1 iPhone and iPod touch app that was designed to be used as a remote for presentations running in Keynote on the Mac. With version 1.4 of Keynote for iOS, the same app can now be used to control a Keynote presentation running on an iPad or another iPhone or iPod touch. Since a wired connection is required to display a presentation from an iOS device, the addition of Keynote Remote support significantly increases the utility of Keynote for iOS in actually delivering presentations, freeing the user to move away from the iPad while presenting. Notably, the feature only works over Wi-Fi, so both devices must be connected to the same Wi-Fi network—Bluetooth could have been an easier way to accomplish this between two iOS devices.
On the iPhone and iPod touch, Keynote 1.4 provides the same functionality as the iPad, again somewhat optimized for the smaller screen. As with its iPad counterpart, Keynote on the iPhone and iPod touch runs in landscape mode only. Keynote on the iPhone and iPod touch does not appear to use the Smart Zoom feature found in Pages and Numbers. All viewing and editing features on the iPhone and iPod touch work much the same as on the iPad, with the only major differences being that the animation mode button is now hidden under the Settings menu—no doubt a concession to more limited screen space—and the use of modal screens instead of pop-over dialogs, as in Pages and Numbers.
With the appropriate Dock Connector video cable, the iPhone and iPod touch version can also be used to display a presentation on an external monitor in the same way as the iPad version. The Keynote Remote app can also be used to control the presentation from another iPhone or iPod touch, or even from an iPad, although the Remote app itself is not universal.
Keynote remains the real gem of the three iWork apps, providing an effective way to manage and deliver presentations right from an iPad. The iPhone and iPod touch versions provide all of the same features and power, and the addition of support for the Keynote Remote app, while seemingly a small thing, has the potential to completely transform the iOS platform as a presentation delivery device. Keynote is head and shoulders above any of the competition, and it’s worth noting that even the other popular Microsoft Office-focused suites came much later to the game in supporting PowerPoint presentations on the iPad—perhaps a testament to how difficult it is to actually get this right. iLounge Rating: B+.
The ability to now use Pages, Numbers and Keynote on the iPhone and iPod touch will definitely appeal to many users, and as universal apps those who own both an iPad and an iPhone can easily have the apps available on both. There are no features specifically missing from the iPhone and iPod touch implementations and as on the iPad, Pages, Numbers and Keynote do a far better job of creating a smooth and intuitive UI than most other word processing, spreadsheet and presentations apps available on iOS devices.
- iOS Gems: A&E Apps, Google Maps, GTA: Vice City, Kindergarten Reading + Rounds: Parker Penguin
- iOS Gems: Angry Birds Star Wars, Modern Combat 4, Real Boxing, Winnie the Pooh + More
- iOS Gems: Animal SnApp, Crazy Taxi, Need for Speed Most Wanted, NBA 2K13 + Zaxxon Escape
- iOS Gems: Bad Piggies, FIFA 13, Rayman Jungle Run, Street Fighter x Tekken Mobile + The Room
- iOS Gems: Blast-A-Way, iTunes Festival London 2012, Splice, Wild Blood + YouTube
- iOS Gems: Avengers Initiative, Little Masters + Wipeout
If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods/iPhones/iPad or accessories, or if you sell or market iPod/iPhone/iPad products or services, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators.
- Happy Thanksgiving 2014 from iLounge!
- Verizon sponsoring ad-free listening to all U.S. iTunes Radio users
- Microsoft, Yahoo hope to replace Google for Safari default search?
- T-Mobile required to fully disclose throttled data speeds
- Steve Jobs biopic picked up by Universal, Fassbender to star
- Handbrake updated to 0.10, adds new encoders + more
- Report: ‘Deep Organizational Issues’ at Apple affecting iCloud progress
- Apple announces Product(RED) Gift Cards for Black Friday
- Apple unveils Product(RED) apps for World AIDS Day 2014
- Apps of the Week: Sago Mini Road Trip, Football Manager Handheld 2015, Deliveries 6.0 + more
- Verus Case Damda Slide for iPhone 6 Plus
- Heckler Design @Rest Stand for iPad (2014)
- Kerf Case Wood Cases for iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus
- Urban Armor Gear Folio for iPhone 6 Plus
- ZeroChroma FluxStand-Compatible Car Vent Mount + Reflective Armband
- Griffin Slim Folio and Survivor All-Terrain for iPad Air 2
- ZeroChroma Slide-Mount Combo Pack for iPad Folio-Slide Cases
- G-Project G-Go Outdoor Wireless Speaker (2014)
- SteelSeries Stratus XL Gaming Controller
- Belkin/Jarden Mr. Coffee 10-Cup Smart Coffeemaker
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of iOS 8.1
- An Easy Guide To Setting Up + Using Apple Pay In iOS 8.1
- Ten Things You Didn’t Know About iPad Air 2 + iPad mini 3
- Mind The Gap: What’s iPad’s Role In An iPhone 6 (Plus) World?
- Editorial: Why I Switched To T-Mobile (And You Might, Too)
- The Early Guide To Apple Watch Apps
- iLounge’s Top iPhone 6 + iPhone 6 Plus Case Picks (Fall 2014)
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of iOS 8.0
- Multi-Editorial: On Apple’s iPhone 6, iPhone 6 Plus + Apple Watch
- What’s New In Apple TV 7.0