iPhone Gems: Every RSS Reader, Reviewed | iLounge Article

Article

iPhone Gems: Every RSS Reader, Reviewed

For those who like to stay as up-to-date as possible with their favorite sites, news, and time-wasters, RSS has become an invaluable online tool. It comes as no surprise, then, that there are no less than 11 RSS reader applications currently available for the iPhone and iPod touch. Ranging from extremely impressive to extremely disappointing, and from free to download to a price of $10, there’s a large variety in this group of apps, which should ensure that there will be something to meet each user’s needs. To see the best of the pack, check out Manifesto and Newsstand.

azRSS NewsReader from VirtueSoft.com

As a simple RSS reader, azRSS NewsReader ($2) falls short of the competition due to a questionable interface and a lack of common, user-friendly features. The app’s main screen lists subscribed feeds along with a “Feeds Directoy” containing roughly 45 different feeds which the user can choose to subscribe to; users may also add individual feeds. The app lacks any sort of feed auto-detection, meaning that users wanting to add feeds not listed in the directory need to remember and type in the complete feed URL (including “http://”), or the app will bring up an invalid URL error. The app’s interface is neither pretty nor offensive, but simply okay.

 

Tapping on a subscribed feed brings the user to the Articles view, where each item is listed with its title and a star for unread or a checkmark for read items; there is no way to mark all unread, or to mark previously-read items as unread. The individual item view page is plain, with text presented in a reasonably-sized serif font. Links clicked from within this view open in the app’s built-in browser. Limited by its inability to automatically find feed URLs, lack of syncing, lack of a flagging option, and hampered by relatively infrequent but still annoying crashes, azRSS would be hard-pressed to garner a recommendation even at the free price level. The addition of any of the above features would help improve this app, which at $2 falls well short of our recommendation. iLounge Rating: D.

Byline from Phantom Fish

Byline ($10) is a Google Reader application for the iPhone. Instead of offering users a list of subscribed feeds, Byline’s simple interface presents a set number of unread articles (25 by default, can be set from 25 to 200) in a smallish font with the source, title, time, and two lines of summary; options at the bottom of the list let the user mark all as read and load more items. Buttons at the top of the screen switch between new items, starred items, and notes views, while a refresh button resides at the bottom.

 

One of the big things Byline has going for it is the ability to archive entire webpages for offline viewing. The app automatically archives starred items and any news items linked to in your Reader account Notes, archived items are presented in a built-in browser, while normal (not archived) items are presented in a simple, standard view with a button to star the item. Links tapped from inside the normal item view send users to Safari instead of the built-in bowser. A menu in the iPhone’s Settings app lets users set the number of unread articles to display and toggle auto syncing, Wi-Fi-only archiving, sort by oldest, offline browsing, and the home screen unread badge on and off.

 

Byline offers many of the features we see as important to its category, such as offline browsing, the ability to sync with an online service, and the ability to star or flag items, but its limited, all-in-one new item view will likely be a huge turn-off for any user with more than a handful of feeds — a major problem, in our view. The ability to view individual feeds and groups of feeds would greatly increase the value of Byline, which currently boasts the highest price of any iPhone RSS Reader. At a lower price, we could overlook some of the app’s shortcomings, but for $10, we feel readers will be better off considering a better, more reasonably priced solution. iLounge Rating: D+.

Feeds from Prime31 Web Design

Feeds ($2) is a fairly straightforward, standalone RSS reader for iPhone and iPod touch. After waiting through an unnecessary splash screen, users are presented with a list of subscribed feeds, along with a starred items option at the top of the list and an add feed button. Luckily, Feeds does offer auto-discovery of feed URLs, so the user need only enter the main domain for the feed they’re searching for. A selection of sixteen feeds, listed only by favicon, sits below the URL text field on the add feed screen.

 

Tapping a feed takes the user to a list of recent entries, with unread items in black text and read items in grey, all listed with the date, time, and title. The individual entry view shows the title at the top in a nice-looking blue box, with the summary directly below, and buttons at the bottom to email a link to the story, star the item, or open the story in Safari — Feeds lacks a built-in browser. Offering the ability to view individual feeds, the option to star or flag items, and auto-discovery of feeds, we feel that Feeds provides enough value at its $2 price point to be worthy of our general recommendation. The addition of syncing, offline browsing options, and a built-in browser would make it even better. iLounge Rating: B.

iRSS from Boris Klaydman

Taking nearly half a minute from launch to actually open and become usable (if it doesn’t crash beforehand, as it did for us more than 50% of the time), iRSS ($5) provides users with an early taste of the shortcomings they’ll find within. The app comes pre-loaded with a modest list of Mac- and Apple-oriented feeds, including iLounge, each listed in the main view with the title, a blue bubble containing the unread count, the time of the most recent update, and the feed URL, an unnecessary addition, in our view. A button for adding a feed takes the user to a rather unattractive page where they can enter a description, the feed URL (no auto-discovery here), and select how many lines of preview text to show and how many items to store. Tapping on a feed takes users to a list of entries, with a refresh button at the bottom and buttons for deletion of items and marking all as read at the top.

 

Selecting an entry takes users to a somewhat ugly individual item view, with a too-small trash icon to delete the entry, a button to mark the item unread, an “enclosure” compass button that did absolutely nothing in our testing, and an action button that automatically sends the user to a new email populated by the summary of the entry, but astoundingly, no link to the article, and no mention of what site it came from — not even the title. Likewise, for sites that don’t provide an extra link to the story in the summary of their feed, there is no way to view the item outside of the summary view — tapping on the title does nothing, and there is no other option for opening the item in Safari, meaning that iRSS is only good for reading the information found inside the feed itself. We could go into further detail on iRSS’ shortcomings, but frankly, there’s no need. For free, this app wouldn’t be worth the download, but it instead sells for $5, making it the worst value of any reader app. iLounge Rating: F.

iRSSFeeds from Gregory Desmaziers

iRSSFeeds ($2) is yet another disappointing standalone RSS reader for the iPod touch and iPhone. With no pre-installed feeds, the app at first presents users with a blank feeds list; an add button in the upper right hand corner lets users enter a description and feed URL. As the app doesn’t offer feed auto-discovery, users will need to remember and correctly enter the complete feed URL for it to work, otherwise the feed appears on the feeds list with a yellow caution symbol and must be deleted to remove it — the app wouldn’t allow us to edit a feed with an invalid URL.

 

Tapping on the feed loads the entry listing page, which features a mark all as read button at the top, the title, date, and time of each entry listed in small, cramped text, a grey dot to the side to denote unread status, and no lines between the entries, making choosing an item rather difficult. The entry view itself is sparse, with an Open in Safari button at the top, the title in bold, and the summary underneath. Lacking nearly every feature we consider important for this type of application at this price point, iRSSFeeds falls well short of being worth its $2 asking price. The addition of a syncing option, feed auto-detection, offline viewing, the ability to flag articles, a better interface, and a built-in browser would be a good start on improving this app, which is currently just a step above “complete mess.” iLounge Rating: D.

Manifesto from Mayor Justin

 

Compared to the other RSS reader applications at its price point, Manifesto ($2) is a breath of fresh air: a robust, full-featured app missing only a couple of features. Manifesto uses a bottom-tabbed interface with three options: feeds, new items, and flagged items. The add button lets users add feeds from a direct feed URL, a general site URL, or from a Google Reader account; the Reader option lets users select individual feeds or add all subscribed feeds. In the feeds view, each is listed by title with the favicon to the left and unread count to the right. Tapping on a feed from within this view lists all entries in the feed, including those marked read, each with the title and time or day. An action button allows users to mark all as read or all as flagged.

 

In the new items view, unread entries are listed by feed, in the same order as on the feeds view. The individual entry view lists the title, with the summary below, a small text link to flag the item, an action button to email a link to the entry or open it in Safari, and a button opposite that for “flipping” between the summary view and a browser view. A menu in the iPhone’s Settings app lets users users toggle an option to cache flagged articles for offline viewing, and set the amount of time to keep old and unflagged articles. While it doesn’t offer true two-way syncing, Manifesto is one of the most usable RSS readers for the iPhone OS, with a clean, smart interface, flagging and offline viewing support, a variety of options from which to add new feeds, and a well-implemented built-in browser view. It’s not perfect, but it’s as close as we could expect from a $2 app; true two-way syncing with Google Reader or other online services could make it even better. iLounge Rating: A-.

NetNewsWire from NewsGator Technologies

With a name that should be familiar to any long-time Mac user, NetNewsWire (Free) is the mobile version of the venerable Mac OS RSS reader. Unlike some of the other RSS readers we’ve reviewed, NetNewsWire is meant as more of an accompaniment to NewsGator’s desktop-based RSS readers, NetNewsWire for Mac and FeedDemon for Windows, than a standalone reader. As such, it doesn’t offer the ability to add feeds from the app itself, although users can tap the edit button on the main feeds screen to delete feeds — either from just the iPhone version, or from the entire account. Each feed is listed in its group (if applicable) with the favicon to the left and the unread count to the right. A refresh button can be found at the lower right of this screen, and tapping on a feed brings the user into the entry view.

 

On the entry view, each is listed by title only, unread in blue and read in grey, with a mark all as read button at the bottom. The individual entry view shows the title in a blue bar at the top, with the summary underneath, a next unread button at the bottom, and an action button to email a link or add the story to clippings, which is NewsGator’s version of flagging. Tapping the title opens the story in the app’s built-in browser, or users can tap the “Open in Safari” button to view the entry outside the app. The app’s developer has said that new features are coming in future versions of NetNewsWire, and with a proven track record, we have every reason to believe this app will continue to improve. As it stands, it’s the only iPhone RSS app that offers NewsGator integration, and while it’s not overflowing with features, it is free. We’d like to see it gain offline browsing support, the ability to add feeds on the go, and more, but it still does what it sets out to do well, sports a well-designed interface, and is worthy of our general recommendation. iLounge Rating: B.

Newsstand from omz:software

Possessing dual interfaces and a wealth of features, Newsstand ($5) is certainly the most interesting of all the currently available RSS readers for the iPhone. In vertical orientation (more on that later), the app opens to the feeds view, which offers an edit button for removal or addition of feeds, buttons for access to all unread and flagged items, and a list of feeds, along with buttons for refreshing all feeds or marking all items as read. The add feed menu sports a bottom-tabbed interface, with options for searching Bloglines for new feeds, importing feeds from a Bloglines account or an OPML file, adding a folder for feed management, or adding a feed by URL, complete with feed auto-discovery.

 

Tapping a feed in the main feeds view presents a list of all items in the feed both read and unread, each with the title, date, and three lines of summary, and refresh and mark all as read buttons at the bottom. The individual item view presents the title below the navigation bar, the summary below that, and a bottom bar with a button to flag the item, and eye button for choosing between six different view styles, a talk bubble button for sharing the item via email or posting to del.icio.us, and a compass button to open the item in the built-in browser, from which the user can choose to open the item in Safari.

 

Turn the iPhone or iPod touch on its side, however, and Newsstand becomes a totally different animal. Landscape mode, as it’s called, presents each subscribed feed as a magazine or paper on a shelf, complete with the feed title and most recent items on the “cover.” Users navigate through feeds like they would in the iPod app’s CoverFlow mode, swiping across to move through the options. Double-tapping on a feed opens it like one would a magazine, with two pages presented: entry titles on the left-hand side, and the selected entry summary on the right. It’s a great example of the kind of innovation we like to see from iPhone developers: well designed, unique, and novel new interface solutions for common applications. It’s this kind of innovation that will help propel the iPhone OS forward as a platform; an example of an experience that can’t be found on similar, competing devices.

 

What it lacks in features, such as two-way syncing and offline browsing, Newsstand makes up for with a wealth of import options, a highly-usable traditional interface, and a must-see alternate Landscape mode, the last of which could have easily been sold as a separate application. It provides more than enough value to be worth its $5 asking price, and while the addition of offline browsing and two-way syncing would make it even better, it remains worthy of our high recommendation. iLounge Rating: A-.

sebNews from Sebastian Schimansky

 

sebNews ($4) is a fairly simple RSS reader. The main feeds view offers users an edit button for deletion of feeds, a button to view all unread items, a refresh button, a list of feeds, a “problem” button that lets users reinstall the app’s database should they experience difficulties, and an add feed button. Users may add feeds by entering a URL (feed auto-discovery is offered) or by selecting a site from their Safari bookmarks — a smart option. Tapping on a feed brings up a list of entries listed in small text. Buttons at the bottom allow the user to select all or unread items, mark all items as read, delete feed items or the entire feed, and refresh, while a search button at the top lets users search the feed for a particular word, a feature that is carried over into the main unread items view.

 

In the individual item view, the date and title are listed below the navigation bar, with the summary underneath and a row of buttons on the bottom for previewing the entry in the built-in browser, opening it in Safari, or closing the entry and returning to the prior view. A menu in the iPhone’s Settings app offers toggles for showing feeds that have already been read, and for autorefreshing of feeds. The application offers no syncing options, no offline browsing, and no flagging, all features that would be appreciated in a reader app that costs $4. It’s not necessarily bad, but it’s not outstanding in any way, and with better options available for less money, it falls short of our recommendation. iLounge Rating: C-.

SimpleRSS from Steve Polyak

 

SimpleRSS (Free) is, unsurprisingly, an extremely simple reader application that is capable of handling only one feed at a time. SimpleRSS has no refresh button, so after we changed the lone feed to iLounge from the default (manually, as there is no feed auto-detection), we (thought) we had to go back to the home screen to see our changes. Unfortunately, we were unable to get the app to launch at all after changing the feed URL to iLounge’s feed because we had forgotten to include “http://”; each time this happened, we were forced to delete and then reinstall the application. We were finally able to load a different feed, but this experience served to make it even more obvious that reader apps should include an auto-detect feature. Once the feed is loaded, there is no indication if an item is read or unread, and tapping on an entry simply opens it in the app’s built-in browser, instead of showing the summary first. There is no way to sync feeds, no way to flag items for later reading, and no offline capability. SimpleRSS is free, but with the inability to read multiple feeds and the lack of many common features, it isn’t a worthwhile app, and falls short of even our lowest recommendation. iLounge Rating: D.

Web Feeds from Tuomas Artman

 

Listed as “Feeds” on the Home screen, Web Feeds ($4) is yet another straightforward RSS reader application. The main feeds view offers a list of feeds with favicon on the left and unread count on the right, a refresh button, an edit button for sorting and deletion of feeds, and an add button for adding feeds. The add feed screen is very simple, with a single field for entering a feed URL or the URL of a site offering a feed. Tapping on a feed opens the entry listing, which lists each entry’s title and three lines of summary, along with a blue dot to the left denoting an unread item. A checkmark button marks all items as read.

 

The individual entry view presents the title in a blue box, above a light grey box containing site, date, and author information, with the summary below. Tabs on the bottom let the user switch back and forth between summary and web page views. A menu in the iPhone’s Settings app lets users choose whether or not to refresh feeds on startup, and set how many items to keep. Unfortunately, Web Feeds strikes us as yet another “okay” app that is done in by its price. At $2, Web Feeds would be at least generally recommendable; the extra $2 added on to its price knocks down its rating substantially. The addition of offline browsing, a flagging option, or feed syncing, combined with a price reduction, would improve this app’s standing, which currently falls short of our recommendation. iLounge Rating: C-.

« Eleven Things You Didn’t Know About the 2008 iPods

New playlists not appearing on iPod »

Related Stories

Comments

1

These are such good reviews, but could you order them in descending order by rating?  Or have a summary of the ratings at the top with links to the individual review anchor?

Posted by Jeremy on September 8, 2008 at 4:47 PM (CDT)

2

I think I’ll wait until Mobile Safari supports feeds Natively.
None of my RSS feeds are that important that I have to read them constantly throughout the day. Maybe in the future, but not now.

Posted by Dan Woods on September 8, 2008 at 4:55 PM (CDT)

3

I know that google-reader isnt a standalone app, but running it through mobile safari its works great, and has nearly all the features that “big” google reader has.

Posted by James on September 8, 2008 at 5:22 PM (CDT)

4

I’m addicted to RSS feeds when at a computer; but when out and about I probably don’t have time for them other than an occasional check.

That makes NetNewsWire perfect for me.  It’s got a clean and crisp interface, but the most important part is that it syncs read/unread status with NetNewsWire on my Mac, which is priceless when you’re getting hundreds of articles per day coming in.

Some of the other apps look interesting, but unless they offer a desktop version, for free, that rivals NetNewsWire, and that syncs read/unread between desktop and iPhone, I just don’t see any benefit in trying them personally. 

Nice review though.  I agree with a previous post that it would be nice to see a summary.

Posted by DistortedLoop on September 8, 2008 at 6:42 PM (CDT)

5

I use Netnewswire on my iphone and sync my feeds with both my imac and macbook. I agree that it would have been much better if it had offline browsing features.

This was such a long article, I would have liked a summary, including price and features comparison

Posted by Zulhilmi on September 8, 2008 at 7:04 PM (CDT)

6

I personally don’t see a need for a separate app when Google Reader works so well.  Unless your feeds contain the full text you’re going to have to launch a browser anyway, so you may as well start out in a browser window.  It also has the advantage of always being in sync.  The only downside is it won’t let me read by oldest post first.

Posted by hardcle on September 8, 2008 at 8:52 PM (CDT)

7

Sweet, I’ve been meaning to install an iPhone RSS reader for a while now. Seems like Manifesto at $2 will fit my needs…

Posted by Webomatica on September 8, 2008 at 10:20 PM (CDT)

8

I’m writing this on a Touch, and actually linked to this article using NewsNetWire.  Although I’m purchasing an iPhone next month (and hoping a surprise 32GB iPhone is released tomorrow), I’m using the Touch in the meantime. As a result, I don’t get cached web pages with this RSS program, and that’s annoying. I can update before leaving a wi-fi enabled area, but if I want to read more, I’m in trouble, even with THIS website. For some reason, some sources send everything except pictures, and others only provide a summary. I’ve become an RSS junkie, because I’ve found that I can keep track of all the news I’m interested in (papers, Yahoo, Apple news, iPod news, and AppStore news. RSS is so much easier. If NewsNetWire can include the ability to cache web pages, it will be a winner…for the iPod and the Touch.

Posted by Doctor on September 8, 2008 at 10:32 PM (CDT)

9

I am using Google Reader and it works so well, I cannot imagine replacing it. I have tried and it doesn’t work.

It has a very simple interface with not submenu navigation and lightning fast load times

Posted by Nikolay Andreev on September 9, 2008 at 2:03 AM (CDT)

10

Use Instapaper to keep Offline versions of websites.

Posted by Oliver on September 9, 2008 at 5:36 AM (CDT)

11

I also rely on Google Reader, as it allows me to keep in sync from the various different computers I use. But on the iPhone I would like to have offline mode (for the subway in NYC or to avoid high data roaming costs when traveling abroad without hotspots nearby). Manifesto is very nice, but two-way syncing with Google Reader would make it a killer app for me (and others I know)...

Posted by Kevin on September 9, 2008 at 6:42 AM (CDT)

12

The problem with Google Reader is I don’t like google tracking EVERYTHING I do:  the read my email, they log my searches, and GR lets them track what stories I follow and actually read.  It’s just too much information for one company to have about me.

I’m not saying Google is evil or anything like that, but why put all your eggs in one basket, especially when that basket (Google Reader) isn’t the best RSS reader out there (in my opinion)?

Posted by DistortedLoop on September 9, 2008 at 8:47 AM (CDT)

13

If I actually cared about who knew what articles I read in my feed reader or if I cared about who knew what i searched for I might feel the same way that DistortedLoop does.

Fact is, for me, I just don’t care. Yes, Google scans my Gmail to serve relevant ads to pay for the free service. Yes, Google tracks my searches. So does every other search engine and I prefer Google Search. Yes, Google tracks every news story that I read. So does every other provider. I like FeedDemon and Net News Wire because I can sync multiple computers. They track my habits.

Given that SOMEONE will be logging this information I use what I like and I like Google. I don’t see it as one company having too much information about what I do, I see it as picking someone to trust and I trust Google.

Besides, I (like so many people) have absolutely nothing to hide and am rather certain that if someone did read my emails or look at my feeds they would find me to be totally uninteresting. Dare I say even boring. That makes it pretty easy.

Posted by dualsub2006 on September 9, 2008 at 11:59 AM (CDT)

14

I was excited by the article, but disappointed by the results.  I agree with James that Google Reader suits most of my needs, but using a Touch rather than an iPhone means that offline reading would be the one feature missed by relying on GR.  But it looks like to get off-line reading, I give up the syncing, which is the main reason I use GR.  The only reader that seems to support both is Byline, which sounds like it has other issues.  Still, I’ll have to investigate it further because no other reader looks to fit my needs any better than Google Reader.

Posted by Rob E. on September 9, 2008 at 12:21 PM (CDT)

15

If I am going to flag stories to get them for offline reading, well, frankly it isn’t really worth much to me.

I want a Google Reader compatible browser that just flat out downloads every single story and then syncs back up to the mothership as I read and star them.

Posted by akatsuki on September 9, 2008 at 2:02 PM (CDT)

16

As a user of Newsgator.com (at work) and NetNewsWire for Mac OS X (at home), I find NetNewsWire for iPhone to be one of the most frequently used apps, even more so than Safari. It is far from perfect—the latest version (1.0.9) is buggy (won’t remove read articles ever) and is missing critical features (e.g., landscape browsing, reading clipping, offline browsing). But I am certain the app will improve and address most of my concerns in the near future.

Posted by nutmac on September 9, 2008 at 6:37 PM (CDT)

17

If you’re willing to jailbreak, GRIS is an excellent (and free) program that syncs to Google Reader more robustly than ByLine.  You can star items and keep items as unread if you want, images are cached locally, and you can select which tags you do and do not want to sync.  It does lump all articles into a common feed, but if you’re clever with which tags you want to sync, it’s not quite so annoying as Byline’s all-or-nothing approach.  Did I mention it’s free?

Posted by What TOS? on September 10, 2008 at 7:15 PM (CDT)

18

Take it from me I have tried them all.

Google Reader’s iphone optimized site is the best, but a little slower than a native app that caches.

Next best is just as ilounge said is Manifesto. All it lacks is two way sync. Their review was accurate.

Newstand’s “landscape mode” is EYE CANDY. It compromises funcionality by cutting the screen in half for something you don’t need to see constantly. Get rid of that & it’s tied with Manifesto. So this is NOT ranked second in my book.

NetNewsWire is what I would rank as second. It has the two way sync and is FREE, but it lacks a few desirable features.

The rest don’t even compare as is.

Posted by Randy on September 14, 2008 at 9:20 PM (CDT)

19

Bought Newsstand.  Wanted to like it so much, and the first few minutes are a joy.  The landscape mode is utterly gimmicky and unnecessary however, and it forgets, IT FORGETS what you’ve read and not read.  10 times today upon loading, it’s brought me to the same damned article I read earlier that morning, and has display loads of read articles as unread.  This renders it virtually useless.  Going to check out Manifesto.

Posted by Paul allen on September 23, 2008 at 4:30 PM (CDT)

20

What drove me to NewsStand over NetNewsWire was that to add a feed to NNW, you have to do it in NewsGator, and since I don’t use a reader elsewhere (I have feeds I read on my phone, feeds I read at the computer), any sync feature I don’t need.

Yes, the landscape view is useless to me, but I really like being able to add a feed from the app.

However—without cut and paste <ahem> it’s still limited in NewsStand, because it uses Bloglines to search for the feeds, and 50% of the time it can’t find the thing I’m looking for.

So I’ll check into Manifesto and see if it suits my needs.

Posted by Wayne on September 30, 2008 at 7:24 PM (CDT)

21

Manifesto has potential but it completely locks up my iPhone backups in iTunes. Latest version (v1.0.2) as well as previous version.

Uninstalling Manifesto puts my backups right back into working order.

Not worth the headache at this point.

Rich

Posted by Rich on September 30, 2008 at 10:57 PM (CDT)

22

I haven’t tried it yet, but I hear that Byline is now in 2.0 and incorporates browsing feeds by tags.  It’s also discounted for a limited time.  I plan on grabbing it as soon as I get home.  If I had an iPhone, I might be happy with another reader, or just the Google Reader web interface, but as an iPod Touch user, the ability to cache stories, read them offline, and then sync back to Google Reader is key.

Posted by Rob E. on October 15, 2008 at 1:46 PM (CDT)

23

Also, you seem2 have missed the most popular
and one of the oldest: Free Rss

Posted by Pranay Sanghavi on October 16, 2008 at 7:37 AM (CDT)

24

Thew new Byline definitely deserves a second visit, with it’s lower price (I know it says limited time, but like what most developers have done, I’m guessing this is a fib, or at least it will only go up to $5 from $4 - $10 is too much), browse by group, and all around polished interface for offline browsing. It’s pretty much exactly what I’ve wanted for rss on the bus, especially since it syncs with google reader so I don’t have to go through everything twice.

It’s biggest remaining faults would be the 200 item limit (which is reasonable for me, that’s about half a day’s content), and the time it takes to sync offline content (start it before your shower in the morning :))

Regardless, a D+ is very unfair to the current release/price.

People keep saying how wonderful the google reader is online, but there are major problems with it, because 1) it requires you be online, which is rather an issue for touch users, and 2) it frequently reloads when you come back to it from browsing another tab linked from your rss. Until this little “feature” of safari’s limited caching is resolved, using google reader is an effort in frustration.

Posted by devwild on November 2, 2008 at 12:21 PM (CST)

25

Agreed, the new Byline is a “2.0” level of maturity versus Manifesto which has a “1.0” feel.  Unless you must have feed level reading (versus folder level), anyone considering Manifesto should skip it and go with Byline.

Posted by byrc on January 14, 2009 at 10:47 AM (CST)

26

From this review I would choose Manifesto but well ermmm… not quite all the rss readers out there: Gazette, boltreader to name just two…

Posted by Josef Rosie on September 18, 2009 at 2:33 PM (CDT)

27

This is a very good overview, but I am missing something: I am searching for an rss reader that can handle feeds that have a url starting with https://.. and that need authentication. Is one of the reviewed ones able to do this? Is there any reader out there that can handle this?

Posted by rodion on October 4, 2009 at 8:12 AM (CDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods/iPhones/iPad or accessories, or if you sell or market iPod/iPhone/iPad products or services, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy