iPhone Gems: Twitch Action Games, Crazy, Cool, or Kusoge | iLounge Article

Article

iPhone Gems: Twitch Action Games, Crazy, Cool, or Kusoge

Our latest game-focused edition of iPhone Gems is here, and the topic is simple: action! We love twitch action games, and of course have been hunting around for worthwhile ones to play on the iPod touch and iPhone.

This week, we picked a collection of titles that caught our attention due to cool titles, interesting themes, or reader recommendations, and though there are a bunch of duds in the pile, there are some worthwhile games as well. Skip right to De Blob and Space Buster/Ikanoid if you want to see the week’s best picks.

Apache Lander

Have you ever wanted to crash an Apache helicopter? How about a dozen Apache helicopters? Now you can, or rather, you will regardless of whether you really want to. PosiMotion’s new game, if you can call it that, is nothing more than a screen with a landing pad that’s supposed to provide a target for you to land a helicopter on. As with any number of other iPod touch and iPhone games, however, Apache Lander (Free) gives you no ability whatsoever to calibrate or even see the on-screen vehicle’s controls, so you’re basically flying blind. All you have is a fuel gauge that is basically there to let you know you’re going to smash into the ground automatically if you don’t land quickly.

Thus, what you’ll see over and over again is a helicopter somehow rolling from left to right to left to right on the screen, typically hovering for a while before you smash it into the ground. An explanation from PosiMotion: “Please note that sometimes the accelerometer does not register in the game. Please restart the game and/or restart your device to resolve the issue.” Right. PosiMotion, we’ve been waiting for weeks to have your smart idea parking space finder application G-Park properly pinpoint our position on a map. We paid for it. And we don’t like being taken to your web site every time we finish crashing ten helicopters into the ground. Please consider giving up the awful game development and focus on getting your other apps working properly. Even for a freebie, Apache Lander sucks. iLounge Rating: F.

Audi A4 Driving Challenge

“Located in Denver, Factory Design Labs, Audi’s interactive agency of record, designed the game in just two weeks,” bragged Audi’s press release for the Audi A4 Driving Challenge (Free, aka Audi A4 Challenge). No doubt. This free simulator shouldn’t be confused with Sony’s 10-year-old Porsche Challenge, or really any other cool driving game released in the past two decades. Instead, it’s an overhead-view game where you’re doing nothing but maneuvering around test tracks filled with orange cones.

Drive poorly, as you probably will, and you’ll either hit a bunch of cones or steer so far outside of them that you won’t really be racing the course. In order to keep you from driving off the edges of the screen, the game basically pilots you around all of the curves of the track automatically anyway, so that you’re basically just trying to keep the iPhone or iPod touch turning gently enough—like a steering wheel—to stay on the road. Fun? Interesting? Informative about the Audi A4? Absolutely not. In fact, playing this is discouraging us from wanting to take a test drive; if driving the real car is anything like this, we’ll stick to what we’ve got. iLounge Rating: D.

De Blob

For the last few weeks, we’ve been trying to figure out whether THQ Wireless’s De Blob ($7) was actually worth paying for. The screenshots didn’t exactly sell it, and we couldn’t figure out what type of game this was supposed to be from the descriptive text, either. Well, here’s the skinny: you control a gelatinous blob that roams around an overhead map of a city, covering buildings and the ground in paint. You’re given certain targets to paint in certain colors, so properly locating paint canisters to transform your blob into the right color is one part of the challenge, and then growing it to a certain size—basically, by absorbing more or less paint—is another. Touch water and you can shrink down, which is sometimes necessary to squeeze through passageways; crash into friends to get new mission objectives, and enemies to knock them out.

What we really like about De Blob is its originality and sense of having been designed as a complete real game. When you see how mediocre a job Audi A4 Challenge does at making an overhead map-based game exciting, De Blob’s constant action—even though it’s very imprecise based on touch-dependent controls—is at least legitimately fun. There are 16 different levels to go through, each with multiple mandatory and optional objectives, and though it’s possible to get a little distracted and lost, the interest level involved in finding the right paint colors and following arrows to tag targets is reasonably high by current iPhone game standards. The $7 asking price strikes us as high considering the overall quality of the art and control experience here, but there’s actual music in the title and enough levels that you’ll probably want to play through the whole game. It’s worthy of a solid B, and if it goes cheaper, perhaps a bit more. iLounge Rating: B.

Ikanoid (subsequently renamed Space Buster)

Taito created Arkanoid, which was perhaps the first game to properly reinvent Atari’s classic paddle-and-ball brick busting game Breakout. And with the exception of the Arkanoid titles, we’ve never played a clone that quite captured the same level of magic. Storybird’s Space Buster/Ikanoid ($1) tries to duplicate Arkanoid, and does well enough at its current asking price to be worthy of your attention, but even after several point releases continues to demonstrate the gap between professional and budding game developers.

Space Buster has all of the prerequisites—simple touch-based control of your paddle, a collection of power-ups that expand or shrink your paddle, create multiballs, or even add lasers to blast bricks—and now includes a little background music, 55 different levels, and particle-like brick exploding effects. But you lose your power-ups after every stage, and it’s missing compelling level designs; there are some stages that feel utterly boring until and unless you hit a multiball to start destroying three or four bricks at once. So far, neither this nor Break Classic really seems to have gotten the formula perfect, but we’d put them in generally the same league; we’d pick Break Classic for the more interesting art and graphics engine, but Space Buster is currently good enough to merit our flat B rating. iLounge Rating: B.

Puzzloop

Ah, Puzzloop. We knew you on Click Wheel iPods as Zuma, after PopCap Games took this game—originally developed by Mitchell—gave it a different coat of paint, and released it with Apple for $5. The concept was interesting: a cannon’s in the center of a spiraling collection of variously colored balls, and you have to shoot balls from the cannon to match up colors before the spiral reaches you. Now the game’s being sold for $8 for the iPhone and iPod touch by Hudson Soft.

The good news: Hudson and Mitchell’s version is a lot more colorful than was Zuma, and this game is a bit more challenging thanks to additional on-screen obstacles, such as flying bats that can block your shots. The bad news: instead of using the comparatively intuitive Click Wheel for control, iPhone and iPod touch users need to touch the screen to rotate the cannon around, which can be a challenge given both the size of the spiral and the way that Hudson has designed the controls to fire a ball when you release your finger from the screen. Simply trying to move the cannon to make color matches can be a problem since your finger may be overlapping the balls you’re trying to shoot; lifting your finger to check results in a ball being fired anyway. While this port would have been great for the iPhone at a lower price and with different controls, it’s on par with the older iPod version as-is, just for different reasons. iLounge Rating: B-.

Shovel De Touch

To quote from the App Store description of Junpuusha’s Shovel De Touch ($3): “This game will realize your childhood dream that you used to want to operate an excavator.” We’ll pause for a moment so you can read that again. Including the part about $3.

Shovel De Touch is a Japanese simulation of a construction site dirt excavator. You get two on-screen joystick-like controls for the excavator arm, enabling you to move the arm into different poses, as well as moving the excavating claw at the end. Lest you think for a moment that you’re actually going to excavate anything in this game, or be able to, say, move the vehicle around, rest easy: you can’t. Instead, Shovel De Touch puts shadows on the screen to challenge you to move the excavator’s arm into various “poses.” You do this until you have beaten your previous record for putting the arm into these poses. And if you’re in the mood, you can try a Balloon mode where you use the arm to pop flying balloons.

In Japan, where it was developed, Shovel De Touch would be described as “kusoge,” a word with a meaning that we can’t print here. It’s almost staggering that this title is being sold for anything, and that the App Store is filling up with software of this caliber. We spotlight this only because the title is so ridiculous and because the comments on the App Store—normally a breeding ground for fake positive reviews—are so amusingly angry. iLounge Rating: F.

Toy Bot Diaries

First things first: hats off to IUGO Mobile Entertainment for trying to make an original iPhone OS game with novel gameplay, device-optimized artwork, and a reasonable price. Toy Bot Diaries Entry 1 ($4) is a platform game of sorts, which means that you’re walking and jumping from platform to platform while interacting with objects, though this isn’t the same type of platformer as Super Mario Brothers, Sonic the Hedgehog, or other famed entrants in that category. It’s actually more of a cerebral, puzzle-oriented game, where the fact that you’re walking around isn’t what’s important; rather, you’re trying to find ways around obstacles that have been placed in your way.

Your character, a toy robot, wanders through stages in an effort to recover cell phone-shaped “datapads” that contain pieces of his lost memory. He has a grappling hook, activated by touching certain surfaces, and magnetic boots, which both enable him to stick to special surfaces and attract certain items. At some points, you’ll be grappling from wall to wall, while at others, you’re trying to figure out how to use your magnet boots and hook together to pull a quarter above some gears, deposit it in a slot, and then trigger a door to open. There are four levels, each with multiple parts, and the “Entry 1” name suggests that there are more to come.

While Toy Bot’s a cute and pretty smart game with pleasant music, it’s still not in the same league with platformers we’ve played on top handheld devices. Put aside the bugs—we’ve walked through a closed doorway, found our game in progress erased, and so on—and the platform game that’s left is so-so on control, relying on tilt gestures to move your character and touch gestures to activate the hook and boots, their inaccuracy tolerable only because the game is forgiving and not on a timer. It’s obvious that IUGO is trying hard to make a game that uses the device well, and that they’ve delivered more actually developed software for the price than many of the brazen people out there, but we’d wait for the inevitable sequel to see what this team can really do. Serious portable or console platform game fans will either breeze through Entry 1 or stop shortly after starting; others may find the action more compelling. iLounge Rating: B-.

Earlier iPhone Gems features can be found here.

« iPhone Gems: Every Movie Finder + Trailer App, Reviewed

iPhone Gems: Every Personal Finance Application, Reviewed »

Related Stories

Comments

1

I can’t believe you gave Toy Bot Diaries a B- rating. This is by far the best platform game for the iPhone yet. It is challenging, especially as you try to complete each level with all datapads. The controls are truly innovative (and not nearly as awkward as others have indicated). The graphics and responsiveness are incredible without slowing your iPhone processor to a crawl, like some games have done. And I didn’t notice the “bugs” you mentioned at all.

I agree that it is way too short. I completed the game (albeit with only slight more than half the data pads) in probably 6 clock hours of gameplay, but those hours were spent trying to figure out ways around various obstacles, and the method of defeating the boss is genius, IMO. I’m hoping the developers release more levels as free updates, rather than making me pay for more chapters, but I will gladly pay if they choose the latter.

I typically agree with iLounge ratings, particularly for software, but I think you missed this one. Definite B+. Would be an A if it were either longer or free, but I’m not complaining. Good game at a reasonable price.

(For the record, I’m not affiliated with the developer in any way, and I had never heard of Toy Bot until I saw it in the App Store. Just a fan.)

Posted by jasonact on August 28, 2008 at 1:57 PM (PDT)

2

I just wanted to say on the Puzzloop review, that there is an easier way. I agree that trying to swivel the canon around with your finger is awkward at best, and results in terrible game play. But what you didn’t mention (unless I read it too fast) is that you can just tap to release a ball. This is a much better way, as you can tap just past the color you want to hit so your finger doesn’t get in the way. It may only rate a B with this new info, but it’s a much more enjoyable experience tapping to fire than sliding your finger to swivel the canon.

Posted by Dave Boyer on September 3, 2008 at 6:49 AM (PDT)

3

Given that the vast majority of the star ratings for the games in this series of articles seems to be B-, C or worse, why in the world is it still called “iPhone Gems”? Wouldn’t that be all A and A+ scoring titles?

Posted by SteveJ on September 4, 2008 at 8:36 AM (PDT)

4

Regarding Zuma on the iPod - I have to disagree fairly strongly with the iPod control wheel being a good and control for the game. Intuitive, sure, but not good - I found that game frustrating to the point of annoyance because it was so easy to touch the scroll wheel while trying to press the button to shoot, so I’d frequently end up either shooting somewhere unintended, or being so careful about pressing the button that I’d miss my opportunity. I can’t say anything about the control schemes in Puzzloop since I haven’t played it.

Posted by SteveJ on September 4, 2008 at 8:40 AM (PDT)

5

#1: It’s not a great game. It is an interesting demonstration of how the OS can enable tilt and touch game play, but it’s far from the best that these devices can (and will) do.

#2: Fair point; it just depends on how a person wants to play the game. The control scheme that previously worked with the title is a mess to try and use now.

#3/#4: Nothing has ever received an A+ on iLounge. Almost nothing receives an A these days. So to use your criteria, nothing would be featured in these columns. Since not everything in the world is a diamond, we pick titles that might interest our readers, and cover a lot of semi-precious stones. This will change as apps get better for the platform.

On your latter point, you said “good,” we said “comparatively intuitive.” So you’re disagreeing fairly strongly with something you said, not us; both games rated a B-, which is less than good (B or B+) under our rating system.

Posted by Jeremy Horwitz in East Amherst, NY, USA on September 4, 2008 at 8:59 AM (PDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods/iPhones/iPad or accessories, or if you sell or market iPod/iPhone/iPad products or services, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy