iPod Add-Ons & iPhone: What You Need to Know | iLounge Article

Article

iPod Add-Ons & iPhone: What You Need to Know

Author's pic

By Jeremy Horwitz

Editor-in-Chief, iLounge
Published: Saturday, June 30, 2007
Articles Categories: Reports

The iPhone, Apple has said numerous times, is three products in one: a cell phone, an Internet device, and Apple’s best ever iPod. Except, as users are finding, it’s not exactly an iPod. Try to use it with one of the over three thousand iPod accessories out there and you’ll probably be surprised by the results: you can’t upgrade it with a larger video display, use it in the car with many recent FM transmitters, or fully enjoy its multi-functionality while it’s connected to most iPod speakers. Here’s what we’ve discovered so far.

Important Initial Tip: If you’re having problems with the audio output from your iPhone, make sure that you’re properly using iTunes’ and iPhone’s Sound Check features. Buried in iTunes’ Preferences under Playback, this odd but useful iTunes feature can be activated to figure out the proper volume levels for all of the songs in your iTunes library, so that music coming out of your speakers stays at a consistent volume without huge spikes or valleys. If it’s not activated, iTunes may not have the Sound Check volume levels for the songs in your library.

As with iPods, iTunes sends any Sound Check data it collects for your songs to iPhone. In the past, this data sat on iPods unused unless you similarly activated the Sound Check feature in their settings menus. Now, unlike iPods, iPhone comes with Sound Check turned on, which is a problem if iTunes doesn’t have stored data. Consequently, iPhone output to accessories can vary wildly in volume, and appear to be capped at a level much lower than the iPod’s. If you’re experiencing major volume problems with your iPhone and accessories, turn Sound Check off until you’re sure iTunes has collected all the data to make it work properly.

What happens when iPhone is connected to common Apple-made iPod accessories?

Nike+iPod Sport Kit: Does not work at all. iPhone displays “This accessory is not supported by iPhone.” message.

iPod Camera Connector: Same as above.

iPod Radio Remote: Same as above, except that it occasionally displays another message.

Notice anything about all three of these accessories? They all have the word “iPod” in their names. None works with the iPhone. But the reasons are different from accessory to accessory. The iPod Camera Connector historically treated iPods as mass storage devices for transfers of digital cameras’ pictures, but iPhone doesn’t operate as a mass storage device, and lacks “Disk Mode” for storing files like a hard disk. For this reason, devices accustomed to reading or writing to an iPod’s database without iTunes just won’t work. Sorry, iLoad. By contrast, Apple could and might add support for the Radio Remote, and while it could do the same for the Nike+iPod Sport Kit, it could also just release an updated Sensor compatible with iPhone’s existing wireless hardware. Whether or not this happens is up to Apple, but we’re not holding our breath—if full-sized iPods aren’t Nike+ ready, why would iPhone be?

What happens when iPhone is connected to certain common third-party iPod car accessories?

Belkin TuneFM: Does not appear to work at all as an FM transmitter. Displays “This accessory is not made to work with iPhone” screen. User is asked, “Would you like to turn on Airplane Mode to reduce audio interference (you will not be able to make or receive calls)?” and given a yes or no option. Pressing any TuneFM button calls up “iPod accessory attached” screen.

DLO TuneStik: Displays those warnings. Allows remote control of simple iPod features. No tuning for FM transmitter. Pressing transmitter button calls up “iPod accessory attached” screen.

iTrip with Dock Connector: Displays those warnings. Sometimes works as an FM transmitter to play iPod audio through radio.

XtremeMac AirPlay Boost: Displays those warnings. On-screen radio tuning for FM transmitter does not work at all. Tuner remains set to whatever channel you last set with an iPod. Does broadcast properly to that station on previous settings unless you hit buttons.

XtremeMac RoadShow: Combines a Dock Connector-based car charger with audio and video outputs. Displays warnings; iPhone charges but does not perform audio or video.

Old FM transmitters may or may not work with iPhone. It doesn’t allow accessories to fill up its screen with text, even on a “Do Not Disconnect” screen, so any accessory that used that method for tuning no longer works fully, or in some cases, at all. Remote controls may work for simple iPod features, but if they have other features, they may not.

What happens when iPhone is connected to iPod Voice Recorders?

iPhone does not support iPod Voice Recorders such as Belkin’s TuneTalk Stereo, Griffin’s iTalk Pro, or XtremeMac’s MicroMemo, and does not appear to have any ability to store voice recordings, except for its essentially unrelated Visual Voicemail feature.

What happens when iPhone is connected to certain iPod speakers?

We’d heard rumblings back in January that TDMA noise—the sound emitted by cell phones when they communicate back and forth with towers—was going to make iPod-ready speakers less than iPhone-ready. Our initial testing bears this out: unless it’s in Airplane Mode, iPhone puts out loud TDMA noise no matter which speakers it’s around (computer speakers, iPod speakers, and so on), and if the speakers aren’t well-shielded, you’ll hear the noise. Apple offers you the choice to turn on Airplane Mode every time you connect iPhone to an accessory, and sometimes keeps nagging you with it over and over, depending on how the accessory “talks” with iPhone.

Bose SoundDock: iPhone charges and speakers work, but with mild TDMA noise unless Airplane Mode’s on. Nag screen came up multiple times during one test.

Altec Lansing iM7: Dock does not close. iPhone charges and speakers work, but with loud TDMA noise unless Airplane Mode’s on. Nag screen came up once during test.

Apple iPod Hi-Fi: Nag screen appears, but speakers work.

Macally TunePro: iPhone charges, but speakers do not work, even if Airplane Mode’s on. Moderate TDMA noise. Nag screen came up once during test.

In other words, depending on the speaker you’re using, iPhone may put out a lot of interference, or a little, or no audio at all.

What happens when iPhone is connected to portable video displays?

iPhone may charge and output audio to their speakers, but it can’t display video on the external display. iPhone does not output video through its headphone port or its bottom Dock Connector, the latter something that could change in a software update, but isn’t guaranteed to do so. iPhone physically does not fit properly inside Sonic Impact’s Video-55, but does output audio. It also does not fit properly in Memorex’s iFlip, and doesn’t output audio. It does not fit at all in Philips’ DCP850.

What happens when iPhone is connected to third party headphones?

Virtually any pair of headphones you try to connect to iPhone—save for Apple’s—simply will not fit the device’s recessed headphone connector. You’ll need an adapter from Belkin, Griffin, Monster Cable, or Shure, selling for between $10 and $40. More expensive adapters, like Shure’s, include a microphone that converts your old stereo earphones of choice into a telephone call-ready option. Less expensive adapters, like Griffin’s and Belkin’s, only let you listen to music. Brand new iPhone-ready earphones, such as v-moda’s Vibe Duo, fit in iPhone and include both earbuds and a microphone.

Conclusions

There are thousands of iPod accessories out there now, and each accessory has likely been manufactured in multiple versions—most without the consumer’s knowledge. As such, the only people who can certify whether accessories are fully safe to use with the iPhone are their manufacturers, so we strongly suggest that you use the iPod Directory we’ve assembled to find the web sites and online support forms for major vendors you’ve purchased from. Though these companies aren’t (generally) to blame for iPod accessories not working with iPhone, their sites and customer service representatives should be best prepared to provide you with guidance as to whether their products are iPhone-friendly. For now, the bottom line is: prepare to have to buy all new accessories again if you want to expand iPhone’s capabilities, and hope that Apple remedies some of its incompatibilities and nagging with software updates in the near future.

« iTunes library on a external hard drive on Windows XP

Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of iTunes 7.3 (Updated) »

Related Stories

Comments

1

Not unexpected, except for the freaking earphone plug issue. As earbuds are easy to misplace, it’s insane for Apple to expect you to have a spare set with the funky plug or to have the adapter handy. The is probably the only anti-consumer design feature, and it’s really annoying.

Posted by Aceon6 in New England, USA on July 2, 2007 at 9:51 AM (PDT)

2

Etymotic ER-6i, iLounge’s highly recommended phones, do work with the iPhone.  Tried it at the store.

Can you give further clarity on the whole “cannot play line-out while charging thing”?

I use a Belkin Auto-Kit to connect to my car stereo.  I understand the TDMA noise might make this undesirable even if it does work, but I’d still like to know if it plays and charges like my iPod.

Posted by alexarch in Dallas, TX on July 2, 2007 at 1:56 PM (PDT)

3

And who in the God’s Green Earth is listening to ELO?

Posted by alexarch in Dallas, TX on July 2, 2007 at 1:57 PM (PDT)

4

Here is a thread in the forums members are giving feedback with a list of products that do and don’t work with the iPhone.

Posted by Audrey McGirt on July 3, 2007 at 3:55 PM (PDT)

5

Although most headphone jacks don’t fit the recessed hole in the iphone, buying a special adapter is completely unnecessary. It took me about 30 secs to shave off about 5mm of plastic from the jack of my Shure EC3’s so that it would fit.
I can send pics to anyone interested

Posted by jeremyc on January 10, 2008 at 10:35 AM (PDT)

6

The Fix when using the ipod radio remote; I notice that if you insert the 30pin connector slowly half way, you will hear a slight connection sound with your headphones, just before the annoying message shows up, let the ipod touch/iphone recognize it for about 5 seconds and then insert it all the way and that’s it enjoy!

Posted by Fernando on January 12, 2011 at 11:34 PM (PDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods/iPhones/iPad or accessories, or if you sell or market iPod/iPhone/iPad products or services, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Shop for Accessories: Cases, speakers, chargers, etc.