An Update On Screen Protection For The Third-Generation iPad | iLounge Backstage

Backstage

An Update On Screen Protection For The Third-Generation iPad

Just like the iPhone and iPod, some people leave their iPads completely bare, risking dents and scratches. Other people use cases and/or protective film to keep their devices looking factory fresh until they’re ready to sell or hand down to a lucky family member. Because our editors have witnessed (and occasionally experienced) the sort of damage that drops and scuffs can cause, we prefer cases, and many of us have used protective screen film, too—at least until recently. Apple’s ultra-sharp Retina Displays have heightened awareness of a long-standing issue with some screen protectors known as the “prismatic effect,” by which plastic shields can scatter each tiny pixel into its rainbow-colored components, transforming a crystal clear screen into a glittery mess. Cheaper films often scatter the pixels in a pronounced way; better-made films from Japan and Korea often have less prismatic distortion, but not zero, and cost more—as much as $30 per sheet for the iPad.

A low level of prismatic distortion was tolerable—not ideal—with iPad and iPad 2 screen film; Apple’s earlier 1024x768 displays didn’t beg to be examined up close, and seriously benefitted from protection, particularly anti-glare coating. Fitted with anti-glare screen film, these iPads became much safer and easier to use in cars and generally outdoors, where they would otherwise be highly reflective, accidentally redirecting sunlight towards users and onlookers’ faces. Top films also dramatically reduce the impact of fingerprints, cutting an iPad’s wipe-down needs from daily or weekly to bi-weekly, monthly, or even bi-monthly. The only noteworthy offset in the best film we tested was a very modest blur, which softened the edges of pixels in a generally inoffensive way.

 

When Apple added a Retina Display to the third-generation iPad, quadrupling the number of pixels in the screen, it didn’t “break” previously-developed screen film; it just magnified existing film flaws. The previously slight blurring in anti-glare films softens new iPad screens enough to make them look closer to their iPad and iPad 2 predecessors—not identical, but not as sharp. Moreover, the prismatic effect now reflects four times as many dots, creating a rainbow-like shimmering that’s particularly pronounced in white parts of the screen, but apparent elsewhere, as well. For the first time in years, we’ve found ourselves peeling off currently available screen film in favor of a bare display—not because we don’t want the glare and fingerprint reduction, but because they make the new iPad’s screen look bad. Crystal clear film, depending on the vendor and model, typically offers great protection and superior visibility, but no anti-glare and limited anti-fingerprint benefits.

 

We wish we had better news to report on the accessory front. After the new iPad was released, we reached out to leading iPad 2 screen film vendors to see if they were planning anything new, and disappointingly, there hasn’t been any update from the Japanese film experts at Power Support, which previously made the best anti-glare film we’d tested across earlier Apple devices—in fact, the company is currently selling its “HD Anti-Glare Film” (shown in the photos here) as “compatible with the iPad 3.” Leading Korean rival Spigen SGP is working on new options, and has already sent us a sample of its perfectly clear but prohibitively expensive GLAS.t, but hasn’t said anything on anti-glare film. Other companies are continuing to sell or bundle the same films for the new iPad as they used for the iPad 2, which most often looked noticeably worse than Power Support’s and SGP’s versions, and will be particularly problematic on the new iPad. Simplism’s new anti-glare films went on our iPads only to be removed quickly thereafter due to distortion.

 

All of this leads to a simple recommendation, at least for now: unless you’re OK with compromising the performance of the Retina Display, don’t buy iPad 2 anti-glare screen film for the new iPad. At $30 per sheet, the cost is too high for a solution that noticeably compromises the clarity of the 2048x1536 screen. Our hope is that developers are working on improved solutions, but the continued silence suggests that users might be waiting for a while. We’ll be sure to share any updates as soon as we have them.

« The New iPhone: Size, Screen + New Connector (Plus iPod touch)

A Note On Smart Covers, Smart Cases + Third-Generation iPads »

Related Stories

Comments

1

The silence just to show it’s the biggest scam in the history of scams, most use film developed by 2-3 big manufacturers eg. 3M, they have no answer since no new ultra-clear films are developed, no big film manufacturer will R&D just for i-Screens so we may be waiting for a while, and truth be told, you don’t NEED a ‘screen-protector’, 9/10 times it just detracts the user experience, once the screen is on I don’t notice finger-prints and anti-glare? no thanks, I don’t want to go back to the 80’s monitors with desaturated blacks and fuzzy graphics, rant over ;)

Posted by sam on April 15, 2012 at 8:49 PM (CDT)

2

If you want anti-glare and anti-fingerprint coverage, then I think image quality will always suffer somewhat. But for me, the reason I insist on screen film is for screen protection—because a scratch on a glass display is permanent! You will be profoundly irritated by a central screen scratch—I Ifound that out the hard way with my iPhone. But I don’t want to sacrifice image quality too much, so the clear screen films are quite nice, and should get more frequent mention from the tech crowd.

Have a clear film from Speck on my ipad2 that works great but even better than that….the Verizon store in my neighborhood has Incipio clear screen protectors on their display table New iPads and the image quality is amazing. I would never have known a film was even on except for the cutout around the front sided camera.

Posted by Charles on May 6, 2012 at 3:45 AM (CDT)

3

I bought the Moshi AG iVisor for my 3rd gen iPad and was really very disappointed by the image distortion.  I actually prefer the slight visual smoothing of a matte screen, but the resolution loss here was too severe.

However, I was super pleased with the Aduro Anti-Glare Membrane on my iPhone 5.  Aduro does not appear to make protectors for iPads, only phones, but now I have to wonder if some of the thinner matte screen protectors would work acceptably for my iPad.

Both are retina displays, so I wonder what gives.  And if anyone has found a matte protector for their iPad 3 that they like better than the Moshi, I would love to know about it.

Posted by Sophia on November 5, 2012 at 10:59 PM (CST)

4

I use a brand called eaglepro from amazon. Saw it on fat wallet. was pretty cheap so I grabbed one. To my surprise the quality of this product is quite good. very clear, no rainbow or image distortion. Maybe my eye just can’t see them. Lol.

Posted by ivision on November 25, 2012 at 1:18 AM (CST)

5

Any updates on this?

Posted by Dan on July 18, 2013 at 8:23 AM (CDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods or accessories, or if you sell or market products, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators. Wondering why we're talking about something other than iPods? Check the Archives: Backstage has been here and kicking it since 2004.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy