Backstage: Why iLounge doesn’t run rumors | iLounge Backstage

Backstage

Backstage: Why iLounge doesn’t run rumors

picRumors. Even though they’re occasionally exciting and could generate even more traffic for the site, we have steadfastly refused to cover them on iLounge. We didn’t make this decision to curry favor with Apple, but rather because rumors are so notoriously unreliable, especially when Apple products are involved.

After all, Apple has a history of cancelling completed projects at the very last moment, so even something that was tantalizingly close to being true (post-Newton PDA, anyone?) can become false via last-minute cancellation. And then there’s the iPod mini, which was vaguely “known” to exist a bit before the official announcement, just at the completely wrong price ($99? $199?) and specifications (2GB).

Sure, it’s tempting to at least put up news stories mentioning the rumors, especially when everyone “just knows” that a new iPod must be coming soon (many people have been predicting an announcement each month for six months now) and since so many of the rumors were supposedly “confirmed by reliable sources.” ...

[Entry continues at the Read More link below.]

A few months ago, prevailing rumors focused on new iPods with color screens, digital photo playback, and possibly limited video features. These rumors were fueled by knowledge that such features are supported by a more recent chipset made by current iPod chip supplier PortalPlayer. They were given faux additional credence when Sony introduced a similarly featured device called the VAIO Pocket, which confirmed that such a package was feasible. And the rumors were only half squashed by Steve Jobs’ public comments that audio, not video, is what people want to carry around. After all, he didn’t rule out digital pictures, and Belkin’s current iPod accessories do the same general thing, right?

Those rumors have since disappeared, replaced by new ones. The latest rumored iPods are halfway between 3G iPods and minis in physical size, designed to replace 3G iPods with similar and even larger storage capacities, and featuring new colored shells (purple, yellow, and orange) apparently designed to appeal to… well, the French, and Dennis. And the supposed announcement date of these iPods: early August. Which is to say, just enough after my birthday not to qualify as a potential gift. But oh how convenient for the holidays.

Are any of these rumors actually true? No one outside of Apple really knows, and again, even if they’re right today, they could be wrong tomorrow. That fact is the reason Apple hates rumor reporting so much: you or I might delay today’s new iPod purchase in order to wait for something that we hear is coming out, yet may never actually be released.

Apple probably has between five and ten different prototype iPods in testing right now, some with current 3G iPod cases, better battery life, and wireless capabilities, others with smaller cases and fewer parts, and some with color screens and photo/video playback capabilities. Any one could become the next iPod, or a totally different Apple product, or never be shown to the public at all. Fact is, not one of these possibilities really matters until we can try it and possibly buy it.

Instead of reporting on and lending credence to rumors, we figured that better avenues for iLoungers’ (and our) imaginations are “we wish” editorials/articles like Future Pods and the ever-popular iPod Concepts gallery. There sorts of formats let iPod lovers explore their fantasies without any suggestion that they’re necessarily going to happen… as much as we might all hope that they would.

What do you think Apple will do with the next iPod to be unveiled? Will it be this year? Next year? A radical improvement on current iPod features, or a compromise between existing iPod designs? Your comments, as always, are welcomed.

« Backstage: Coming soon, for July 17 2004

Announcing Backstage.iLounge.com »

Related Stories

Comments

1

“Apple probably has between five and ten different prototype iPods in testing right now, some with current 3G iPod cases, better battery life, and wireless capabilities, others with smaller cases and fewer parts, and some with color screens and photo/video playback capabilities. Any one could become the next iPod, or a totally different Apple product, or never be shown to the public at all. Fact is, not one of these possibilities really matters until we can try it and possibly buy it.”

This may well be the best sum-up of rumors I’ve come across. Being someone who sees probably more than his fair share of Apple rumors, you couldn’t be more right. R&D is an interesting game/job/whatever, and product development depends on trying every idea, whether it works or not. It’s ultimately up to the reader to decide which rumors sound most likely/feasable, and how that possibly incorrect information should impact them.

Posted by Mudbug on July 15, 2004 at 10:40 AM (CDT)

2

I heard that they are getting rid of the WHITE iPod completely!

Posted by Coolpepper43 on July 15, 2004 at 11:48 AM (CDT)

3

they wouldn’t get rid of the white ipod, it’s the original and there would be an uproar from all the third party designers with white ipod accessories, and I want to know why everyone seems to want a colour screen on an mp3 player?

Posted by Zer0cool on July 16, 2004 at 10:44 AM (CDT)

4

people just want the most they can possibly get out of a tiny electronic device. thats why they want color screens. ask around, ask people what theyd like in a tiny hand-held electronic device: video? audio? digital potography? peoples imaginations go crazy thinking about stuff like this, and i think thats what leads to so many rumors - people start thinking about all this stuff theyd like to see in an iPod and when they hear some small rumor with some information slightly similar to what they want and they get really really excited. they go out tell everyone and it eventually ends up here or on other messageboards, forums, etc.

people, just because youd love to see a holographic videophone in an ipod doesnt mean theyll make one with it (leave those ideas for the concept gallery).

Posted by shane on July 16, 2004 at 12:57 PM (CDT)

5

Remember, back when the iPod mini came out, Apple began to refer to 3G iPods as available only in “Signature iPod White.” This was as clear a sign as any that Apple views the white casing as distinctively iPod.

That’s why we believe that Apple almost certainly will not phase out white iPods entirely. At worst, they’ll become the high-end of the iPod line while most of the sales are done in cheaper colored models like minis. This would parallel the branding strategy of Mont Blanc, which emphasizes its most expensive (and distinctive) pens over its cheaper, and more common looking ones.

Posted by Jeremy Horwitz on July 17, 2004 at 11:15 AM (CDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods or accessories, or if you sell or market products, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators. Wondering why we're talking about something other than iPods? Check the Archives: Backstage has been here and kicking it since 2004.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy