Early Hands-On Thoughts on Apple’s Magic Trackpad (Versus Prior Mice + Trackpads) | iLounge Backstage

2014 iPad iPhone iPod Buyers' Guide from iLounge.com

Backstage

Early Hands-On Thoughts on Apple’s Magic Trackpad (Versus Prior Mice + Trackpads)

Author's pic

By Jeremy Horwitz

Editor-in-Chief, iLounge
Published: Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Backstage Categories:

I am smack dab in the center of Apple’s target demographic for the just-released Magic Trackpad—a MacBook Pro user for years, huge fan of Apple’s trackpads, and a consistent purchaser of Apple’s desktop mice. Note that I used the word “purchaser” rather than “lover” for that last one. I loved the one-button Apple (“Pro”) Mouse, but was less thrilled by its subsequent replacements: I was a day one purchaser and rapid abandoner of the Mighty Mouse, as well as a day one purchaser who just sorta learned to live with the Magic Mouse. Apple makes beautiful mice and great trackpads, but hasn’t made a truly great mouse in a while. So a desktop-ready trackpad just made sense when the first pictures of the Magic Trackpad leaked out of China. Unlike Wacom’s earlier multi-touch tablets for Macs, the Magic Trackpad looked perfect—elegant, metallic, and big. I waited nearly two months after that leak for it to actually be introduced, then bought it the day it went on sale. For $69. That’s a lot of money, and $20 more than the basic Wacom Bamboo Touch, but basically par by Apple pointing device standards. It’s arguably worth the investment if the experience is great.

So how is it? My initial reaction is that it has the potential to become great, which is incidentally how I felt about the Magic Mouse after spending some time with it. The Magic Mouse is Apple’s best-looking mouse, ever. As a one-button solution, if you’re okay with the low profile and modest hand adjustment you need to go through to accommodate it, it might even come close to greatness. Except that the batteries need to be replaced all the time, which is ridiculous. And the multi-touch surface on top doesn’t really support gestures I care about, while the inertial scrolling still creates major problems with applications I use, such as Adobe’s Photoshop and InDesign. It’s a gorgeous mouse with software issues that never seemed to get fixed.

On paper, the Magic Trackpad was supposed to solve all that. It’s a bigger version of the MacBook Pro trackpad that I love—except for the occasional errant right button clicks that happen because there’s no dedicated right button on the uniform, matte glass surface. Did I mention that I love that glass surface? It feels great, looks great, and so should be even better on the Magic Trackpad because there’s more of it. Apple built the Trackpad to exactly match the height and depth of the Apple Wireless Keyboard—not the wired version, which I use daily and think is even better than Apple’s mice. In concept, the big Magic Trackpad should have enough space for dedicated left and right button surfaces, so no more errors, right?

Well, that depends. In one of those classically “huh?” Apple engineering decisions that will take a little time to fully appreciate or curse (see, e.g., the now-discontinued Mighty Mouse’s scroll ball), Magic Trackpad’s button—and it does appear to be a button, singular—is actually underneath the unit in the form of two gray rubber dots that would otherwise just be keeping the thing in place on a flat surface. If you’re using the Magic Trackpad on a totally uniform desk, and most people probably will, that’s no problem: clicking on the surface works and feels just like it does on a MacBook, more sensitive at the bottom than the top. On my particular desk, though, which just happens to have a grid of holes that are oddly sized to perfectly fit the ones on the Trackpad’s bottom, the clicks won’t register at all if the Trackpad’s sitting or shifted to the wrong space. Most of the time, I use my computers and accessories just like anyone else, but because my desk’s a little unusual, this is one of the rare situations where that’s not the case. Solution: slide Magic Trackpad further down my desk where there’s less wrist support. There, it works without issues. Unless I push it upwards, or the pads collect dirt like the Mighty Mouse’s scroll ball. Again, it’ll take a little time to know whether this happens; I’m betting that it won’t.

The other surprise of Magic Trackpad is that the larger touch surface isn’t yet translating into more accurate control over my computer. It might look square from a distance, but the surface is actually a little over 5 inches wide and around 4.3 inches deep, with an extra near inch for the twin AA battery compartment in the back. That’s more than enough room to extend past my centered fingers on either side, while providing adequate room for multi-finger gesturing, two-finger scrolling, and so on. Unfortunately, Apple still doesn’t offer the sort of touch surface user customization that would make the most of this trackpad. I’ve set the System Preferences panel to recognize right clicks as “bottom right corner”—one of only two choices (“bottom left corner”) Apple offers. Five inches turns out to be quite a distance for fingers to travel just to make a right click. Using the MacBook’s former “two-finger tap/click” gesture tends to introduce accidental right clicks into my workflow with some frequency. It’s here on Magic Trackpad and causes the same errors. I’ve turned it off for now.

Back when the Magic Mouse was released, my hope was that Apple would update the drivers with better gesture support, hopefully adding an expert user mode that offered precise control over what portion of the top surface would be recognized as a right click—or just a “left side means left click, right means right click” feature. That never happened. Apple released the Magic Mouse, offered a bugfix that was supposed to stop nasty-quick battery drain, and then left it alone. A third-party tool or two came out and demonstrated that the Magic Mouse’s surface was a really sophisticated sensor that could be programmed to do a lot more, or just work better. Apple hasn’t taken up that cause.

For the past several years, Apple has been using a problem analysis methodology that essentially relies upon users to complain—loudly and in great numbers—before the company will consider the possibility that something’s not right with one of its products. These days, Apple resolves problems only when people (a) report them in huge numbers through Mac OS X’s or iTunes’ bug reporting tools, or (b) call into AppleCare at a rate of, say, 0.55% of the entire userbase while simultaneously picketing Consumer Reports’ offices. Apple surely hasn’t received enough bug reports to reach the conclusion that some users aren’t totally thrilled with the way its mice or trackpad buttons work, because there’s no bug reporting tool for errant button clicks. And it takes a lot of bad clicks before someone’s going to waste the time to call AppleCare only to be told that there’s no known problem.

The same thing could well wind up happening with the Magic Trackpad. Unless there’s a semi-fixable and widely documented problem like the Magic Mouse’s quick-draining battery, the Trackpad extension might not be updated for a while, and its multi-touch surface might wind up being underutilized, like the Magic Mouse’s. That would be a shame, as it has so much potential.

But with two-finger right-clicking disabled, it’s also working pretty well right now as a mouse alternative. We’ll see how much enjoyment I get out of it over the next couple of months, and whether battery swaps are as necessary as they’ve remained with the Magic Mouse. I’m guessing and hoping the Magic Trackpad will be better—if Apple’s new $29 rechargeable battery kit is mandatory, that’ll be a real bummer. And I’m also assuming that I’ll adjust enough to using the Magic Trackpad that the small initial issues will fade quickly from memory. I want to love it. With a little time and adjustment, say nothing of an Apple software update, perhaps I will.

« An Update on Apple iPhone 4 Case Program Picks, With Q + A

On iPhone and iPad Screen Protection: Why It Matters + Some iPhone 4 Results »

Comments

1

Bit rich of Apple to claim the “new Magic Trackpad is the first Multi-Touch trackpad designed to work with your Mac desktop computer” when the Wacom Touch and Pen & Touch have been available for almost a year now.
While it blends in nicely with the current range of Apple keyboards, the ability of the BT devices to devour batteries is off-putting - high capacity NiMh rechargeables seemed to pack up quickly if the device wasn’t turned off which in itself becomes a bit of a pain every time you leave your desk.
I’m all for cutting down on cables but not at the expense of having a wall full of battery rechargers…

Bluetooth paper lit and standing back…

Posted by Bob Levens in UK on July 28, 2010 at 2:15 PM (PDT)

2

Bob, Apple’s claim is technically correct.  The Wacom devices you mention are *tablets*, not trackpads.

Posted by didymos! on July 28, 2010 at 2:31 PM (PDT)

3

Hmmm, is a trackpad not incorporated into a laptop just a tablet?

Posted by Bob Levens in UK on July 28, 2010 at 2:43 PM (PDT)

4

I wasn’t aware of a Magic Mouse battery fix - mine still drains pretty darn fast.  Any link for info?

Posted by Jay P on July 28, 2010 at 2:53 PM (PDT)

5

If you’ve run Software Update and nothing has downloaded, you already have the ‘fix.’ Apparently battery drain was worse after it first shipped because something didn’t turn off when the mouse was paired with a wireless keyboard. Now the problem is mostly limited to situations when your Mac doesn’t go into sleep mode and winds up eating the mouse batteries overnight. Any time the Mac is doing something like a big wireless sync, I come back to it and the batteries are dead or near dead.

Posted by Jeremy Horwitz in East Amherst, NY, USA on July 28, 2010 at 3:05 PM (PDT)

6

Like the iPad: It’s cool in a way that makes me wish I could think of a use for it.

Posted by Farnsworth on July 28, 2010 at 5:05 PM (PDT)

7

BetterTouchTool now supports the Magic Trackpad. I have not used it for this purpose but really love it for my MacBook Pro trackpad. I am thinking of getting a magic trackpad but the price is quite steep considering I have a smaller one built in.

Posted by Jiji on July 29, 2010 at 5:49 AM (PDT)

8

As a brief update to this piece, the Magic Trackpad is already feeling like a complete (and superior) Magic Mouse replacement less than a week after starting to use it. It takes a little time to adjust to using it, and both the right-click and desk-related issues persist, but there’s a lot to like here. Six percent of the batteries have been drained after 5 or 6 days of use, which is to say that run time of roughly three months would be expected from a single set of non-rechargeable AAs.

Posted by Jeremy Horwitz in East Amherst, NY, USA on August 2, 2010 at 10:55 AM (PDT)

9

Apple is going too far with making everything wireless. (Except for iPhone stereo audio, but I digress.) Since this is meant for desktop computing, wouldn’t a wired version make sense? To that end, I sent the following to Steve Jobs:

“The Magic Trackpad is nicely done. However, wireless (e.g. Bluetooth) isn’t for everyone. As the Apple Wired Keyboard has side facing USB ports, why not introduce a wired Magic Trackpad with a short USB cable (one that can run in either direction), that can easily and neatly connect to the keyboard - and thus connect both peripherals via a single USB port?”

And his answer was, “No plans to make a wired version.  Sorry.”

Posted by Farnsworth on August 4, 2010 at 7:43 AM (PDT)

10

Just got this today, and in the space of a couple of hours I’m really digging this thing…!!

I did need to completely uninstall USB Overdrive though so that I could run the setup correctly, but it’s a joy to use so far, and I love the inertial scrolling.

Given my recentish lack of confidence in BT devices on OSX, I’m impressed with this so far.

Will have a look though at BetterTouchTool - cheers for the info.

Posted by Albert on August 4, 2010 at 7:52 AM (PDT)

11

I got mine the day after it came out and so far I’m really liking it. After seeing some of the capabilities in Better Touch Tool, I think this device has a ton of potential and could drive user interface/interaction changes in full OS X. Which is maybe what Apple has plans for in the long run.

Jeremy, that’s a cool desk and a really unfortunate pairing for this device. Instead of moving it to a different location though, why don’t you just find/make a super thin (1mm), 1x5 inch metal plate to place under the feet? Ideally, it would have a thin layer of rubber/cork/non-slip coating on the underside to prevent slippage. If this doesn’t exist for some other purpose already, I would think you could easily make it for under $5.

I understand people’s complaints about it being unnecessarily wireless, but there also seem to be quite a few people who aren’t using rechargeable batteries for Apple’s peripherals. Why is that? I got a large pack of Eneloops (I believe Apple’s new silvers are the same quality) plus a charger from Costco 2 years ago for under $30 and use these for all wireless mice/keyboards in the house. As soon as I switch out drained for charged, I start recharging them. The batteries last much longer than normal batteries and don’t seem to have lost the ability to hold a charge. Good, rechargeable batteries are a win from any angle (much cheaper over time, performance, convenience, eco friendly), so it seems odd that so many people still don’t use them.

Posted by skip on August 4, 2010 at 1:08 PM (PDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods or accessories, or if you sell or market products, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators. Wondering why we're talking about something other than iPods? Check the Archives: Backstage has been here and kicking it since 2004.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Shop for Accessories: Cases, speakers, chargers, etc.