Editor’s Notes: 2007 Buyers’ Guide, iLounge Editorial Policies
Now that we’ve finished the 2007 iPod Buyers’ Guide (well, mostly), I wanted to publish a few editor’s notes for those people who might be interested in behind-the-scenes details on how we put these things together, and what makes our publications different from ones you might find elsewhere.
Editorial Independence. You probably already know that we don’t sell iPod accessories or services, and that we’re not owned by or connected to Apple or any third-party accessory/service provider in any way. On that note, I say and sincerely mean this: when we assemble our Guides, we do so with absolutely zero editorial interference from the companies we cover, Apple included. Just as with iLounge.com, we create these downloadable publications with one goal in mind, and that’s to better inform our readers about the increasingly incredible world of iPods and accessories. We’re not trying to sell anything - that’s the job of Apple and its third-party developers - we’re just here to provide an objective, independent overview of what’s in the market.
No Paid Placement or Advertorial Content. iLounge is firmly and entirely opposed to paid placement of products in editorial sections of our Guides and our site, and we do not ever - ever - create “advertorial” content. For those unfamiliar, paid placement is where a publisher requests or accepts money in exchange for, say, putting X product on page Y of a publication. And advertorial content is a disclosed or undisclosed mixing of advertising with editorial content - say, an article devoted to how company Z’s products can improve your life, funded by company Z and written with their oversight. We do not and will not do these things, but can say with certainty that such things do happen in publications marketed to iPod users, and you should be skeptical.
The Process. Prior to assembling our Guides, we make attempts to contact as much of the industry as possible to let them know that we’re about to put together a new edition - typically via press release and/or e-mail. Though we’ve been blown away by the ever-increasing number of companies making iPod accessories (currently well over 300), our process is intentionally designed to be inclusive rather than exclusive, and we try to offer industry coverage that’s as broad and wide-ranging as possible - not just the “big guys” or companies with huge advertising budgets. We continue to be committed to giving smaller, up and coming companies a chance to shine right alongside larger, more established players - our only criteria are that we have to believe a product’s a standout and worth featuring given the total pool of competing options we’re considering, and the company can’t have run afoul of our few but specific rules on deceptive sales practices.
Insane Volume of Submissions. Every time we do one of our Guides, the quantity of stuff we receive for inclusion rises. This one was literally the craziest ever - FedEx and UPS trucks arriving no fewer than 6 times a day during the peak, with DHL and USPS stopping by once or twice, too. It wasn’t unusual for 20 new accessories to arrive in a single day on the heaviest days, and that only tapered off a couple of weeks ago. Only yesterday, after the Guide was published, did we begin the process of digging out from everything; rather than tossing stuff out, we’re always committed to taking a look at everything that comes in the door for possible inclusion if there’s an unexpected last-minute opening in a section.
Exclusions. We don’t make a big deal about this, but after posting a few warnings on iLounge that this was a possibility, we’re now leaving out offerings by companies that have engaged in deceptive sales practices - posting phony testimonials about their products, using anonymous comments to slag competitors’ offerings, or otherwise repeatedly engaging in “bad karma” activities that harm iLounge readers. As a word of warning, we’re going to clamp down even further on this in the very near future, because we’re really tired of the grade school antics and want to re-level the playing field in favor of the industry’s good guys, of whom there are many.
That’s it for now. Comments and questions are welcomed; I’ll do my best to respond to them over the next few days. Hope you enjoyed the new Guide - if you haven’t seen it yet, get it here.
If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods or accessories, or if you sell or market products, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators. Wondering why we're talking about something other than iPods? Check the Archives: Backstage has been here and kicking it since 2004.
- Apple to sell limited-edition Olympic Apple Watch bands exclusively in Brazil
- Report: iPhone 7 will include Lightning adapter instead of Lightning EarPods
- Edward Snowden designing device to prevent iPhone wiretapping
- Report: Apple Car team running into challenges, launch may slip to 2021
- Corning announces Gorilla Glass 5
- Apple under fire for providing refurbished replacements under AppleCare+
- Report: Apple acquires cloud music provider Omnifone? [Update: No]
- Apple releases second iOS 10 public beta
- India clears the way for Apple to open retail stores
- Apple Pay launches in Hong Kong
- Netatmo Tags for Welcome Smart Home Camera
- iDevices Socket HomeKit-enabled Light Adapter
- Koogeek Wi-Fi SmartPlug for Apple HomeKit
- Marbotic Smart Letters for iPad
- Ecoxgear Sol Jam Bluetooth Speaker
- Gumdrop Cases DropTech Case + Hand Strap for 9.7” iPad Pro
- Braven BRV-1M Bluetooth Speaker
- Braven BRV-Blade Bluetooth Speaker
- Invoxia Voice Bridge
- Incase Keyboard Case for iPad Air 2
- Inside the betas: iOS 10 Photos gets Advanced Computer Vision
- Inside the betas: iOS 10 Music app delivers ‘clarity and simplicity’
- Inside the betas: iOS 10 Maps gets a major redesign
- Inside the betas: iOS 10 shakes up the user experience
- Inside the betas: watchOS 3 promises a real speed boost
- Inside the betas: A sneak peek at what’s new in tvOS 10
- Filling the Gap: A look at third-party HomeKit apps
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of tvOS 9.2
- Instant Expert: Secrets & Features of iOS 9.3
- Opinion: Why Apple needs a dedicated HomeKit app