Incipio’s Feather Rivals Speck’s SeeThru Satin For MacBook Air 11” Protection | iLounge Backstage

2014 iPad iPhone iPod Buyers' Guide from iLounge.com

Backstage

Incipio’s Feather Rivals Speck’s SeeThru Satin For MacBook Air 11” Protection

Author's pic

By Jeremy Horwitz

Editor-in-Chief, iLounge
Published: Tuesday, January 25, 2011
Backstage Categories:

There weren’t any custom-fit cases ready when the new MacBook Air 11” was released last year, but cool new cases are appearing almost every week now, and Incipio’s Feather ($50) is the latest to grab our attention. It follows hot on the heels of Speck’s SeeThru Satin, which we looked at yesterday, and has a lot in common with that hard shell design—no huge surprise as both cases are smaller sequels to same-named versions released for earlier MacBooks.

Though they’ve each been rethought somewhat for the 11” Air, Feather is a somewhat less dramatic departure for Incipio than SeeThru was for Speck. Both are less than 1mm in thickness, but Satin is just a little thinner without making compromises on resilience or scope of protection. Incipio’s hard shell is also heavier at around 7 ounces versus 6.7 ounces for Satin, a difference that sounds small but in practice adds just enough extra weight to the Air’s lid to push it down from a semi-open position. From our perspective, this is really a failing of the Air’s overly soft hinge, which has a tendency to fall into an overly open position on its own, but Feather exacerbated the unwanted sway a little more on our machine. Apple may wind up stiffening the hinge in later Air production runs if it hasn’t already, making this difference immaterial, or it might not—the original 13” Air had hinge problems for quite a while before Apple addressed them.

Modest weight and thickness differences aside, Feather is a handsome shell. The soft touch rubber finish feels just as nice as SeeThru Satin’s, making the case easy to grip reliably rather than glossing the aluminum-bodied Mac up to a dangerously slippy level. Unlike Satin, four colors are available—black, purple, red, and pink—and each is opaque, so you shouldn’t expect to see the Apple logo when the computer’s off or on. There are also some neat if not strictly necessary Incase-inspired perforated venting holes on the bottom of Feather, a little design touch that’s completely missing from SeeThru Satin. On the other hand, Feather’s side port holes are slightly less impressively tailored, with too little extra space for wide USB or display connectors, and the rubber foot covers are a little less interesting than Speck’s. The black Feather we received also shows smudges much more easily than the black Satin, picking up and making finger oils look very obvious within moments of first use. This would be our biggest issue using Feather in practice.

Neither company has a price advantage, which is sort of a bummer given that either one could have easily shaved some dollars off the $50 already being charged for the larger MacBook Pro versions of these cases—but then, no one is really competing with equally impressive MacBook Air 11” hard shells at a lower price. We’d bet that Incase will follow suit with its inevitable Hardshell Case for MacBook Air, which though unannounced at this point will probably wind up costing the same price while resembling each design in some significant ways. If and when it appears, we’ll check it out, too; for now, Incipio and Speck have significant early mover advantages, with Speck leading on the little details and Incipio offering more colors and a little extra design flash. We’d give the edge to Speck, but if you’re looking to go red, pink, or purple with your 11” Air, Feather’s your only choice today.

« New iPad details: RFID/NFC add-ons, carbon body, 7” iPad still in works

MacBook Air 11” Gets Moshi’s Muse + Speck’s SeeThru Satin »

Comments

1

The Incipio feather shells are really very nice. They’re minimalist, with a pleasant texture and easily washable. I got one for my iPad (purple) because it was too slippery to carry uncovered. I can rest it on my legs now without it slipping off and carry it around without fear of it crashing to the floor.

Posted by Jeffharris on February 8, 2011 at 4:32 PM (PDT)

2

Is there a difference between the Incipio & the speck shells from a heat standpoint? I bought the latest mid-2011 11-inch & the speck seethru satin black. I feel like the Speck cause way more overheating and was wondering if I should switch to the Incipio.

Posted by Arun B on July 26, 2011 at 8:32 AM (PDT)

3

THREE QUESTIONS:

I second Arun B’s question. I’m leaning toward the Speck, but know the importance of the vents on the Incipio. What to do?

Also, I got an Incipio shell right after getting my refurbished 11” Air, and the case totally blocked access to the thunderbolt port (which I rely on for ethernet connections). After realizing this the hard way, it was so hard to get off that I took it back to the store so as not to end up liable for any damage, and the guy who eventually got it off cracked it at least once.

Does the Speck case leave room for thunderbolt, and is it as hard to get off as its rival?

Thanks for the comparison!

Posted by Amber D on January 24, 2013 at 7:49 AM (PDT)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods or accessories, or if you sell or market products, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators. Wondering why we're talking about something other than iPods? Check the Archives: Backstage has been here and kicking it since 2004.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Shop for Accessories: Cases, speakers, chargers, etc.