One Month With Apple’s 11.6” MacBook Air: It’s A Keeper | iLounge Backstage

Backstage

One Month With Apple’s 11.6” MacBook Air: It’s A Keeper

After years of chasing the bleeding edge and paying higher prices, I’m now accustomed to purchasing “fast but not fastest” computers—I went from a Power Mac G5 and Cinema Display to an iMac, from a 15” MacBook Pro down to 13” MacBook (metal) and 13” MacBook Pro models, and then, in two recent, rapid-fire devolutions, to a 13” MacBook Air and an 11.6” MacBook Air. Though these might sound to some readers like downgrades, they make sense given the way I and an increasing number of people are using computers these days: there’s a bigger-than-ever monitor with strong CPU horsepower at my desk, and a smaller-than-ever monitor with less horsepower for the road.

Last month, I explained that I had picked up and returned a top-of-line 13” MacBook Air, realizing that the space savings it represented over a 13” MacBook Pro wasn’t personally justifiable given its considerably higher pricing, diminished screen quality, and weaker overall performance. Yet its replacement, the new 11.6” MacBook Air, has turned out to be one of my favorite Macs ever. It is the machine I wanted to buy years earlier when Apple introduced the notoriously hot 12” PowerBook G4, which I wasn’t about to put on my lap despite its otherwise appealing form factor. In short, the 11.6” Air has turned out to have all of the assets I was looking for in both the 12” PowerBook and the original 13” Air, and after a solid month of relying upon it alternately as a primary and secondary computer, there’s no doubt: it’s a keeper.

One of the biggest question marks I dealt with when making the purchase was whether the performance differences between the 1.6GHz and 2.13GHz Airs would be noticeable. In practice, at least for the things I’ve been doing, the answer has been no. Due in large part to the solid state memory in the Airs, loading applications, huge photographs, and the like is so fast on even the 1.6GHz model that there isn’t time to stare at the screen and wonder why things are taking so long. There are certainly gaps in application performance that could be and have been measured elsewhere, but in real-world use of the machine for day-to-day tasks, they’re just not noticeable to me. Simple Photoshop editing, multi-window web browsing, and streaming videos from wherever—it all just happens without huge lags.

Another question mark was heat, specifically whether the Air would ever become hot enough to the touch that I’d notice or care. Answer: no. Not once in a month has the temperature ever been an issue, no matter what I’ve been doing with it. My guess is that the 1.6GHz processor was picked for the 11.6” model because it was as fast as Apple could go without running the machine hot or rapidly draining its power. Until there’s something even more efficient out there, it strikes me as a very good choice.

There have only been two hiccups in the past month, one major, and the other minor. The major one is battery life. Apple’s most recent performance metrics still don’t capture the reality that the Air will be dead in under three hours if you’re using it to play back video or do anything else that’s reasonably demanding on its processor. By “under three hours,” I’d say 2.5 or 2.75 hours are common under high-stress situations, even with the screen dimmed somewhat. Leave the Air doing nothing but displaying a previously loaded web page and it’ll stay turned on for a really long time—quite possibly in excess of the promised 5 hours, as estimates have suggested 6 or even 8 hours under unrealistic usage conditions. But for the way I use computers, 3 or 4 hours is about what the 11.6” Air will do, and that just doesn’t feel like enough.

The minor hiccup was partially my fault. I made an impulse purchase while on vacation last month, buying the Viva Elvis CD on a whim when I discovered it on the shelves of a Cirque du Soleil store. Before the transaction was even complete, I realized that I had no way to rip the CD into iTunes in the absence of an optical drive on the Air—the first time I’d ever had a problem like that with a laptop. Since I can count the total number of times I’ve used any optical drive over the past year by using my fingers and toes, this really isn’t an issue for me; I’ve similarly found the Air’s USB ports abundantly capable of handling my I/O needs when connecting an external hard drive. The absence of FireWire, Ethernet, and the like just haven’t mattered to me. Ditto on the bigger speakers of the 13” machines and all the extra space around their keyboards. Given how well the 11.6” Air’s full-sized keyboard works, and how adequate the speakers are under most circumstances, they feel like no loss at all.

One mixed surprise has been the new MagSafe power connector, which I was originally excited to be using—the side-mounted cable on the now metal connector looked like a better design than the centrally-mounted cable on the prior plastic one. In practice, however, the cable doesn’t feel quite right in either direction it can point, obscuring a USB port or hanging straight off the Air’s back, albeit only modestly in both cases. As nice as the new connector looks, the prior style worked better for my needs.

Where the Air really has proved to be awesome is in size. My wife typically inherits my prior-generation computers when I’m ready to move on to new models, and has said that she isn’t quite sure that she’d want to switch from the 13” Pro she’s using to the 11.6” Air because of the smaller screen. But all it takes is having to lift her now hulking computer off of a table for a few seconds, coupled with the simultaneous realization that my machine does virtually everything as well as hers in a smaller package, to confirm that the new Air’s a better fit for my needs. I can stack an iPad on top of it in a bag and still have more room inside than I did with the 13” Pro; the load on my back when carrying it is noticeably lower. Opening up the screen yields a display with more pixels than the Pro, though not, as noted before, as many colors. Under most circumstances, this doesn’t matter.

It sort of did when we were traveling for two weeks and I relied upon the Air as my primary computer. I was never certain whether the pictures I was sending out looked as good on other monitors as they were looking on the Air. When I returned home, I found that they did—they actually looked better. Unfortunately, using the Air doesn’t allow for the sort of accurate color correction I’d really like to be able to do on the road. Apple will eventually get around to fixing this on the Air, but I suspect that its desire to shave off further microns from the next-generation model’s thickness may impede its ability to improve upon the components that could stand to be better in the future.

So is the current-generation 11.6” MacBook Air the best MacBook ever? From where I stand, no. I’ve had Macs that were so close to perfect straight out of the box that it would be hard to imagine something being much better at that point in time. This new model does so much right that I wouldn’t give it up, but also leaves enough room for improvement that I’ll be anxiously awaiting its successor or successors. What I can say with certainty is that it would be virtually impossible for me to consider going back to a 13” machine at this point. Apple picked the right screen size, keyboard, and other components to make this little MacBook feel just right—battery, CPU, and screen tweaks would make it just that much better. And I’m loving NLU’s BodyGuardz for it, too, which have made it feel a lot less delicate despite its tiny frame. If Apple sold the equivalent glossy body protection for the same $50 price—or better yet just used iPod nano 5G-style gloss finish—a lot of people would be very happy to pay a little premium to keep their machines safe.

« Mobee’s The Magic Charger Makes Apple’s Magic Mouse Complete (For A Price)

NLU’s BodyGuardz For 2010’s MacBook Air 11” + 13” »

Related Stories

Comments

1

I like the idea of getting an Air for portability and something like an older generation MacPro with a large monitor for home. What do you do about synchronization? Where do you put your iTunes library for instance?

Posted by Bryan S Schmiedeler on December 4, 2010 at 12:45 AM (CST)

2

iTunes library goes on the desktop machine and a smaller subset goes on the Air for occasional listening. I personally don’t try to sync the machines, but there are programs that keep multiple folders in alignment between two Macs; my view is that the Air is like an iPad, receiving emails and other content that’s also going to my desktop machine, and I’ll share files between them on the rare occasion when something important is downloaded only to the Air.

Posted by Jeremy Horwitz in East Amherst, NY, USA on December 4, 2010 at 7:26 AM (CST)

3

Hi Jeremy,

Great article and exactly the way I use my Air. I had a MPB 15 inch that I gave to my daughter after two months, but I really wanted a 17 inch for home and serious use. The iPad fit the bill but occasionally I need a computer. In comes the Air. I have it where I can reach back via Mobile Me to all of my libraries (iTunes, iPhoto, etc…) and sync them as needed. My daughter does this primarily when she travels. This is the way of the future. Apple hit a home run with this. Of course the Windoze nay sayers are all screaming how the Air is underpowered, etc.. but their arguments are moot in the face of how good this thing really is.

Posted by Don Trammell on December 4, 2010 at 5:24 PM (CST)

4

Thank you Jeremy!

I was so excited and relieved to find this post. I need to replace my 12” PowerBook G4 (purchased 2005), and realize that ANY new Mac laptop will be light years ahead of what I have now. But after fondling the 11” MacBook Air at the store, I’m smitten.

I would use it primarily for going online, sending email, Hulu-ing, storing music and word processing. I don’t do graphic design, but still handle Photoshop and InDesign files from time to time. Do you think the 11” Air can handle my needs?

Thanks again for your very helpful review.

Posted by Claire on December 4, 2010 at 7:03 PM (CST)

5

Bryan,

To keep the Air and desktop in sync, try Sugarsync. It’s automatic, and unlike Dropbox, it will sync folders wherever they are on your computer(s) rather than your having to put them into a Dropbox folder. There is a free version with a generous allocation and paid subscriptions that are cheaper than Dropbox.

Posted by Jeff on December 5, 2010 at 3:27 AM (CST)

6

I moved from a (black!) macbook13 to a mbookAir11 about a month ago, and find it much better in (almost) every way. In the same way that a laptop is a different experience from a desktop, and an iPhone is a different experience from a laptop, an Air11 is a different experience from all of those, something between a laptop and an iPhone. Don’t consider it a netBook. I have had one off those and they just don’t work.

At work I have the Air11 plugged into a 3Mpix monitor and a hub with keyboard and mouse. I program all day, remoted into our Linux servers while simultaneously reading mail and running a browser natively. Note that the Air11 stays closed in this configuration.

When I go somewhere, I disconnect the air11 and take it with me *everywhere*.  If I stop off at a friends house, I automatically take it in with me, showing them my latest photos from iPhoto or music from iTunes.

I normally didn’t do this with the macbook13, it is just too big and heavy for that. Passing an Air11 around between friends is just different from passing a laptop around. the macbook Air11 is really a new kind of personal computer.

Warning to programmers: the esc key is in the top row of keys that are half-size. Kind of a pain but you can get used to it. Of course, when plugged into a monitor and keyboard, this is not an issue.

Posted by blue on December 5, 2010 at 5:37 PM (CST)

7

#4: Yes, it can handle those needs—so long as the InDesign work is both occasional and not overwhelming. We put together 200-page INDD documents twice a year and would not want to rely upon the Air as a primary machine for doing so, but as a backup (or for smaller documents) to be used in conjunction with a color-correct monitor, definitely.

#6: Agreed. The size and weight make it feel like something that you can take to places the 13” might not have seemed appropriate in.

Posted by Jeremy Horwitz in East Amherst, NY, USA on December 6, 2010 at 3:59 PM (CST)

8

I have the original air. Still love it. I fantasize about this new 11 inch air. It will be my next computer, probably in a year or two.

One thing is missing: backlit keyboard. Never thought I needed one til I got the air. Can’t believe they left it off the new models.

Posted by Dick Bacon on December 13, 2010 at 11:52 PM (CST)

9

Nice posting Jeremy!

I have been thinking to get the new macbook air for weeks now. There is something that keeps bothering me to purchase one.  That is the durability issue of solid state drive.  I have read some articles about it and they say that there are still some issues like crashing ,etc.  But I could not find news / issue regarding solid state drive issue on macbook air when I googled.

Do you know about this issue?

Posted by Iman on December 16, 2010 at 7:47 PM (CST)

If you have a comment, news tip, advertising inquiry, or coverage request, a question about iPods or accessories, or if you sell or market products, read iLounge's Comments + Questions policies before posting, and fully identify yourself if you do. We will delete comments containing advertising, astroturfing, trolling, personal attacks, offensive language, or other objectionable content, then ban and/or publicly identify violators. Wondering why we're talking about something other than iPods? Check the Archives: Backstage has been here and kicking it since 2004.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

Recent News

Recent Reviews

Recent Articles

Sign up for the iLounge Weekly Newsletter

Email:

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond.
iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, Mac, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.
iLounge is © 2001 - 2014 iLounge, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy