iLoungeiLounge
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedIn RSS
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms Of Use
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedIn RSS
    iLoungeiLounge
    • News
      • Apple
        • AirPlay
        • iCloud
        • iTunes
        • HealthKit
        • HomeKit
        • HomePod
        • iOS 13
        • Apple Pay
        • Apple TV
        • Siri
      • AirPods Pro
      • Apps
        • Apple Music
      • Rumors
      • Humor
      • Technology
        • CES
      • Articles
      • Web Stories
    • iPhone
      • iPhone Accessories
    • iPad
    • iPod
      • iPod Accessories
    • Apple Watch
      • Apple Watch Accessories
    • Mac
      • MacBook Air
      • MacBook Pro
    • Reviews
      • App Reviews
    • How-to
      • Ask iLounge
    • Daily Deals
    iLoungeiLounge

    Australian consumer commission suing Apple over ‘Error 53’ iPhone failures

    By Jesse HollingtonMay 16, 2021 1:28 pm UTC

    Australian consumer commission suing Apple over ‘Error 53’ iPhone failures

    The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) is suing Apple over last year’s Error 53 problem that disabled iPhones which had undergone third-party repairs, The Wall Street Journal reports. The ACCC, which is an arm of the Australian government focused on consumer law and competition regulation, is alleging that Apple was in violation of Australian laws by “bricking” iPhone devices and refusing to subsequently repair them at no cost to customers on the basis of the devices having been previously serviced by third-party service providers. The regulator is seeking monetary penalties that could amount in up to $829,000 (A$1.1m) per breach if the courts find Apple liable.
    When the Error 53 problem first appeared in Feb. 2016, Apple initially insisted that it was a security measure to protect the integrity of Touch ID security, which relies on a unique pairing between each Touch ID sensor and the internal Secure Enclave that stores fingerprints and Apple Pay credit and debit card data. Several people disputed Apple’s claims, however, since prior to iOS 9, replacing a Touch ID sensor simply disable the Touch ID features and Secure Enclave, leaving the iPhone otherwise operational. A little over a week after the Error 53 problem was first reported, Apple released a fix in iOS 9.2.1 that users could apply to affected iPhones over a USB transfer from iTunes in order to restore their iPhones to normal operation.

    ACCC chairman Rod Sims notes that the lawsuit is looking to deal with the overall issue of third-party repairs, rather than just the Error 53 issue specifically, and that the ACCC is seeking to challenge Apple’s “overall policy of requiring customers to pay for repairs to defective components if their device was previously serviced by a third party.” Sims also notes that from the ACCC’s perspective, such practices are unique to Apple. The regulator’s position on the Error 53 lawsuit is that Australian consumer law requires that consumers are guaranteed that a product they purchase will be “reasonably fit” for its intended purpose, and that this guarantee is “not extinguished because a consumer has goods repaired by a third-party repairer.”

    Notably, Australia is a year late to the game in addressing the Error 53 issue, as lawyers in both the U.S. and the U.K. threatened legal action when the problem first appeared in Feb. 2016; with a class action lawsuit last spring eventually thrown out by a U.S. judge. That said, the Australian lawsuit is the first being brought by a government agency over the issue, and may play out differently under Australian consumer protection laws.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Jesse Hollington
    • Twitter

    Jesse Hollington was a Senior Editor at iLounge. He's written about Apple technology for nearly a decade and had been covering the industry since the early days of iLounge. In his role at iLounge, he provided daily news coverage, wrote and edited features and reviews, and was responsible for the overall quality of the site's content.

    Latest News
    The Apple Watch SE 2 Just Got Even More Affordable
    Apple updates App Store Review Guideline
    iOS 17 developer beta released early
    Apple adds a free tier for its developer program
    Get the Wrist-Friendly Logitech MX Vertical Ergonomic Mouse at $29 Off
    iPhone X and iPhone 8 won’t have iOS 17 support
    New 15-inch MacBook Air with M2 chip launches
    Apple reveals Apple Vision Pro headset

    iLounge logo

    iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond. iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.

    Contact Us: [email protected]

    Tel: +1302-208-9669

    iLounge, 2810 North Church Street, Wilmington, Delaware, 19802, United States.

    • Contact Us
    • Submit News
    • About Us
    • Forums
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms Of Use
    This website is not affiliated with Apple Inc.
    iLounge © 2001 - 2023. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.