iLoungeiLounge
  • News
    • Apple
      • AirPods Pro
      • AirPlay
      • Apps
        • Apple Music
      • iCloud
      • iTunes
      • HealthKit
      • HomeKit
      • HomePod
      • iOS 13
      • Apple Pay
      • Apple TV
      • Siri
    • Rumors
    • Humor
    • Technology
      • CES
    • Daily Deals
    • Articles
    • Web Stories
  • iPhone
    • iPhone Accessories
  • iPad
  • iPod
    • iPod Accessories
  • Apple Watch
    • Apple Watch Accessories
  • Mac
    • MacBook Air
    • MacBook Pro
  • Reviews
    • App Reviews
  • How-to
    • Ask iLounge
Font ResizerAa
iLoungeiLounge
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • News
    • Apple
    • Rumors
    • Humor
    • Technology
    • Daily Deals
    • Articles
    • Web Stories
  • iPhone
    • iPhone Accessories
  • iPad
  • iPod
    • iPod Accessories
  • Apple Watch
    • Apple Watch Accessories
  • Mac
    • MacBook Air
    • MacBook Pro
  • Reviews
    • App Reviews
  • How-to
    • Ask iLounge
Follow US

News › Apple

AppleiPhone

Judge rules FBI can’t order Apple to unlock iPhone in New York case

Last updated: May 14, 2021 3:17 pm UTC
By Dan Pye

A federal judge has ruled the government cannot use the All Writs Act to force Apple to unlock an iPhone, a judgement that could have far-reaching implications in Apple’s ongoing legal battle with the FBI, Reuters reports. While all eyes are on Apple’s public debate with the FBI over whether or not the company should unlock an iPhone used by the San Bernardino terrorists, a similar case has been working its way through appeals courts. Last October the Department of Justice dismissed Apple’s argument against helping the government break into the iPhone of a suspected drug dealer, saying the company’s operating system is “licensed, not sold” to users.

Advertisements

But U.S. Magistrate Judge James Orenstein disagreed with the DOJ’s assessment, stating that he does not have the legal authority to order Apple to disable the phone’s security measures.
Orenstein made it clear that his ruling was not on “whether the government should be able to force Apple to help it unlock a specific device; it is instead whether the All Writs Act (AWA) resolves that issue and many others like it yet to come.” Orenstein contends that the AWA can’t be used in this case and others like it, because the government’s reading of the act is so expansive it would “cast doubt on the AWA’s constitutionality if adopted.” A senior Apple executive who asked not to be named said the decision bodes well for the company in the San Bernardino case, which relies mostly on the same arguments that Orenstein rejected. Although the Brooklyn court’s decision is not binding for U.S.

Magistrate Judge Sheri Pym in the San Bernardino case, the ruling is still influential since it marks the first time Apple used the courts to resist unlocking an iPhone for authorities and will clearly demand consideration given the timing. A representative for the DOJ said the department is “disappointed” and plans to ask a higher court to review the decision.

.
Advertisements

Latest News
The 11-inch M3 iPad Air WiFi 128GB is $120 Off
The 11-inch M3 iPad Air WiFi 128GB is $120 Off
1 Min Read
Apple Planning to Launch Base iPad in Spring of 2026
Apple Planning to Launch Base iPad in Spring of 2026
1 Min Read
The iPhone 17 Air and iPhone 17 Will Have 9 Color Options
The iPhone 17 Air and iPhone 17 Will Have 9 Color Options
1 Min Read
Online Leaks Reveal RAM for iPhone 17 Lineup
Online Leaks Reveal RAM for iPhone 17 Lineup
1 Min Read
The 15-inch M4 MacBook Air 256GB is $150 Off
The 15-inch M4 MacBook Air 256GB is $150 Off
1 Min Read
Apple Back to School Promo Launches in EU
Apple Back to School Promo Launches in EU
1 Min Read
New OpenAI Browser to Debut Soon
New OpenAI Browser to Debut Soon
1 Min Read
Safari Technology Preview 223 Now Available
Safari Technology Preview 223 Now Available
1 Min Read
The Apple Watch Series 10 GPS 42mm is $119 Off
The Apple Watch Series 10 GPS 42mm is $119 Off
1 Min Read
Apple Account Card Might Soon Arrive in Other Countries
Apple Account Card Might Soon Arrive in Other Countries
1 Min Read
Apple Preparing a Customer Support-Type AI Assistant
Apple Preparing a Customer Support-Type AI Assistant
1 Min Read
Play-Doh World Arriving on Apple Arcade
Play-Doh World Arriving on Apple Arcade
1 Min Read

iLounge logo

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond. iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.

This website is not affiliated with Apple Inc.
iLounge © 2001 - 2025. All Rights Reserved.
  • Contact Us
  • Submit News
  • About Us
  • Forums
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Use
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?