Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

Last year, we picked clear, full body film protectors — specifically, the ones from NLU Products — as 2007’s best overall iPod and iPhone accessories. Rather than forcing you to thicken your iPod or render it accessory-incompatible, these films add a layer of highly resilient clear coating to the iPod’s or iPhone’s body, offering everything save waterproof and anti-drop protection. In short, they’re iPod cases for people who don’t like iPod cases, letting you see the device while knowing that it’s not going to get torn up in a pocket with keys or a purse filled with coins. The only problem is that the clarity of these films can be a serious issue, particularly on the screens of Apple’s devices, but also elsewhere on their bodies.

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

As in the past, NLU’s new BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G ($25) and iPod touch 2G ($25) come in boxes with two sets of full body clear film, a squeegee, and a bottle of application solution. Each box includes a warranty that lets you swap a used set of film for a new one in the event that something peels off; your first replacement is the second set in the box. Of the two versions of BodyGuardz, NLU has done an especially impressive job of covering virtually every micron of the new nano’s body: after wetting the film down and applying it, you’ll likely find one thin, sub-millimeter stripe on the back, and one similarly thin circle around the nano’s Click Wheel that aren’t protected. That extent of coverage is just great.

 

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

There’s only one shock: if you try using the iPod nano immediately after application, you’ll find that the covered screen looks terrible.

Due to whatever interaction there is between NLU’s wet film and the newly curved, glass-covered screen of the fourth-generation model, you’ll see a profound prismatic effect on the display that looks like rainbow-colored specks are floating literally everywhere. We were extremely concerned when we first saw these specks—they rendered the nano’s video and game playing modes seriously unpleasant, and even menu navigation was distracting.

 

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

But then we let the iPod nano dry. The rainbow-colored specks began to disappear, and continued to do so until the screen looked pretty close to normal. While we’ve seen clearer static cling screen protectors for past iPod nanos, the new version’s curved screen may wind up presenting challenges to any sort of protector, so it’ll be interesting to see how other products stack up; when dried, this one’s pretty good. The only other complaint some users will have is a slight color-shifting of the nano’s body; for instance, NLU’s glossy film tends to bring out the “black” nano’s grayness rather than making it look like a darker charcoal. We’ve seen this happen with past films, as well.

 

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

By comparison, the iPod touch version of BodyGuardz ($25) is a little less impressive in body coverage. For this model, NLU has created a single rear sticker that is only a modest challenge to attach.

Using the holes for the top Sleep/Wake button, side volume buttons, and bottom Dock Connector port to align the film is easy, but getting the thin strips of side- and bezel-covering film to stay put requires some additional time and effort. After some drying time had elapsed, these strips stayed where they were supposed to be, but didn’t feel totally perfect on the touch’s corners or edges. It’s worth noting that with all of NLU’s film applied, the chrome front bezel wasn’t totally covered, and none of the buttons were covered at all.

 

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

More notable was the fact that the back of the device was prone to showing little bubbles, even after we tried our best to squeegee them out. Unlike the nano’s prismatic screen, which dissipated over time, these bubbles remained after the drying process, and were pretty conspicuous.

 

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

These types of coverage and blemish issues are common to many film protectors for iPods, but not all of them. Consequently, though BodyGuardz provides 90-95% body protection for the iPod touch, it does so with unsightly cosmetic detractors; these were part of the touch version’s slightly lower overall rating.

 

Review: NLU Products BodyGuardz for iPod nano 4G and iPod touch 2G

NLU’s screen coverage was the other small issue.

Share